When Halliday comes back

[RFCRobertson 11,769]

How do you think it'll pan out? The boy got a lot of flack and most of it quite rightfully. However I believe he was thrusted into a position he didn't really know and wasn't offered a lot of cover. 

So with a better formation in place, better players and decent manager. Do you think Halliday would get on better?

And do you think it'd be a better idea to push him forward to a position he might be more comfortable in?

[Essandoh 21,192]

If he was as talented as he is staunch he’d walk this league but unfortunately that isn’t the case. We shouldn’t let time romanticise his performances. He was superb with Holt in the Championship but as soon as he came up against top 6 sides in the Premiership he was shown up.

Even in a ‘new’ formation, I’d still have Jack, Dorrans, Pena, McCrorie, Barjonas and Holt over him every time.

He should be allowed to find a team in the summer. We need better!

[.Williamson. 81,975]

The fuck is with all this talk of Halliday tonight?

When he comes back he can take his place back in the stands. He's fucking awful.

[ForeverAndEver 71,349]

The Mighty Bears will hang himself

[Blue Avenger 22,567]

He'll do ok polishing boots. He can even do that on his erse as well.

 

[BridgeIsBlue 66,595]

Not good enough. 

[Band of Brothers 10,303]

8 appearances since being on loan might come back with a point to prove. Canny slag the lad for passion but needs to step up when he comes back big time.

[McEwan's Lager 30,484]

I would like to see him have a couple of games in his natural position on the left to see what he has in him there at this level.

[King Jela 20,358]

He's pathetically bad tbh. No really understanding this 'forced into an unknown position' shite, he said himself that was his preferred position, he was just utter dog shite in it. 

[siddiqi_drinker 14,635]

He's pish, sell him to Partick or Hamilton or.....

[born a blue nose 90,695]

I'm going to advocate for the devil here and say. 

Give him a chance. 

[Amato 3,016]

@Jamie0202 is gonna be fuming when he sees @RFCRobertson has stolen his thunder .

 

[JR 1,480]

 Not sure he’ll be back at all. 

[wully 47,178]

He's not even good enough to wear Borris's costume never mind Broxi's.

[Tenerife Bear 1,748]

No place for him here. Best getting his agent to call wee McCann or big Tommy or something. 

[left winger 14,105]

He'll join The Union Bears.

[CM 1234 68]

Not good enough. I don’t think he even knows what position he wants to play and it shows 

[DavieBear1954 27]

Might actually be a good idea to recall him for back up incase Jack,Dorrans or McCorrie pick up injuries or suspensions. While on the subject I'd recall Forrester as I feel he's a better player than some of the players who we have in the squad like Dalcio and Nemane.

[Lloyd 10,756]

He’s pish

[scottyc06 6,915]

Would assess him in pre season! A year away might have pushed him to improve, not likely but certainly wouldn’t rule him out just yet 

[Courtyard Bear 41,357]

Not good enough. 

[Laudrup1984 25,100]

I think all returning loanees deserve a shot. I think many if they had their way wanted Windass to get to fuck, Wilson never to play again and thought that Holt was just not good enough. Some probably still hold this opinion. However even their fiercest critics must accept for the past few weeks they have been key in our recent success.

Even now Fod, Tav and Morelos continually receive a lot of stick but again they've been key for us over the season.

In the right system, with the right players, with a manager who believes in him and plays him in a preferred position you never know. Maybe he'll also realise what he could be losing after being away for the last few months.

He wasn't great for us but I think he has ability. Time does hamper your judgement and makes players seem better than they were. His lack of game time this season is also concerning. I don't have an issue though with him coming back, knuckling down and giving us another option. Right now we are becoming more depleted from middle to front by the day and any other options would be welcome IMO.

[plumbGER 24,518]

I'm for giving him a chance, in his natural left mid position though and not in that holding role he was never good enough for.

What other options do we have for that left mid position? Windass is a waste of a jersey out there and is much better playing central.

[KeyserSoze 14,520]

Not at the level we require and I don’t think he’s returning anyway. 

Not many fans get a game at the club you love. 

[OneDavidCooper 2,505]

I'd give him another chance. What do we have to lose?