Murty and these December games

[Bad Robot 21,125]

The questions are about giving Murty the job until end of season.

[Bad Robot 21,125]

Poll promted after listening to the Rangers Radio archives:

http://mixlr.com/rangersradio/showreel/

[BridgeIsBlue 66,549]

No to all three. 

[K.A.I 36,183]

Number 2 for me, but if number 2 applies then number 1 does too.

[Ger_onimo 20,488]

3 minutes ago, BridgeIsBlue said:

No to all three. 

[Prso's headband 35,256]

I don’t think there’s any argument against him if he wins 3 and draws one unless you’re talking an absolute top class manager coming in. 

But if were going to bring someone in like Tommy Wright or Steve McLaren, Murty is the better option. 

Lets be honest what manager is going to come in on the back of us being potentially unbeaten in 8 games anyway.

[cushynumber 25,178]

I would frame it differently. Do you trust our board to get anybody better than Murty for the remainder of the season?

[CoopsLaud 4,184]

Depends how we play against the scum imo. If it is another poor performance he has had it.

[K.A.I 36,183]

If he wins all the games and avoids defeat at celtic Park I'm struggling with anyone that says he shouldn't get the job tbh.

I've then got 2 questions ..

1- What does he have to do to get the job?

2- Who would we get in that could realistically do a better job than that?

I know Murty isn't a big name or who we all crave as our new manager, but I think you've got to be fair and say what else can he do and who else would do better? ... give me an idea or a name.

McInnes' wasn't any good to most people on here because he's only beat celtic something like twice in 4-seasons despite regulary winning the rest of the games in the league and having them in second and Murty wouldn't be any good for us either for the basically the same thing? I hate to deliver negative newsflashes but it's where we are just now and without King's 30-millon to spend on top players a manager who can do the above mentioned things is literally the best we can do.

[Bad Robot 21,125]

2 minutes ago, cushynumber said:

I would frame it differently. Do you trust our board to get anybody better than Murty for the remainder of the season?

I should do a poll but just asking if we trust the board getting any decent manager 

[cushynumber 25,178]

1 minute ago, Bad Robot said:

I should do a poll but just asking if we trust the board getting any decent manager 

another one - is there a standout candidate out there at the moment that we should be chasing? if not then we are better sticking with Murty or we are changing for changings sake

[The Specky Forum Organiser 64,325]

Should have it til the end of the season already.

[Bad Robot 21,125]

10 minutes ago, K.A.I said:

If he wins all the games and avoids defeat at celtic Park I'm struggling with anyone that says he shouldn't get the job tbh.

I've then got 2 questions ..

1- What does he have to do to get the job?

2- Who would we get in that could realistically do a better job than that?

I know Murty isn't a big name or who we all crave as our new manager, but I think you've got to be fair and say what else can he do and who else would do better? ... give me an idea or a name.

McInnes' wasn't any good to most people on here because he's only been celtic something like twice in 4-seasons despite regulary winning the rest of the games in the league and having them in second and Murty wouldn't be any good for us either for the basically the same thing? I hate to deliver negative newsflashes but it's where we are just now and without King's 30-millon to spend on top players a manager who can do the above mentioned things is literally the best we can do.

I wished I made different questions for the  paedos game with maybe asking 

1) if we got beat but played really well?

(For me he gets it)

and

2) if we got convincingly beat.  

(For me he doesn't get it)

[Bad Robot 21,125]

2 minutes ago, cushynumber said:

another one - is there a standout candidate out there at the moment that we should be chasing? if not then we are better sticking with Murty or we are changing for changings sake

It needs to be a stand out IMO

[Bad Robot 21,125]

17 minutes ago, BridgeIsBlue said:

No to all three. 

Even if we’re sitting top?

[RFC55 108,452]

We will be at the fenians with a weakend side. I feel it would be harsh to judge him on that. If he wants the job these 3 games upcoming are bigger than the taigs. If he doesn't win those 3 and even if he does beat the taigs then it's a no for me.

All other scenarios in your poll then yes he keeps it 

[BridgeIsBlue 66,549]

3 minutes ago, Bad Robot said:

Even if we’re sitting top?

If we win the next three and get a good result at the piggery he should get it to the end of the season then see where we are. 

[DeanMK 4,641]

Murty is nothing more than a contingency plan from a lacklustre boardroom. However if he wins all the remaining games this year and takes even a point from them then I can’t really see how you couldn’t give him the job. 

He’ll have stabilised us in a way no manager has done over the last 6 years.

However it’s a big ask for him. We’ll see where we stand come new year. 

[Bears r us 30,757]

I am just going to take it one game at a time, but if he manages number 2 or better then I would give it to him until the end of the season. Sometimes stand in managers do well, then they are given the job and it all goes wrong and they are sacked within a few months, we do not want that after the last two fuuck ups IMO.

We have wasted so much time now and seemingly players being looked at by MA for the next window I cannot see any top manager taking on the job under that conditions.

[Courtyard Bear 41,357]

If we were willing to take McInnes with his record against the scum then that game shouldn’t come into it with regards to Murty. 

[Dado'sMulls 2,607]

14 minutes ago, Rfc52 said:

We will beat the fenians with a weakend side.  

Fixed that for you 

 

For me option 2 would be enough for the job, to have us within touching (not that you want to) distance of that mhob in January was more or less Pedro's remit anyway. Don't really see much point of fixing what isn't broke, unless of course we find an outstanding candidate for the job. 

[.Williamson. 81,855]

23 minutes ago, Rfc52 said:

We will be at the fenians with a weakend side. I feel it would be harsh to judge him on that. If he wants the job these 3 games upcoming are bigger than the taigs. If he doesn't win those 3 and even if he does beat the taigs then it's a no for me.

All other scenarios in your poll then yes he keeps it 

When's the last time we went into a game against the taigs at full strength? I literally can't remember the last time I wasn't thinking the morning of the game fuck sake typical

[GOAT 30,449]

If we go through this entire month without dropping a single point, I'll change my name to Murty.  

[.Williamson. 81,855]

I worry about how nice a guy Murty is tbh. I like the guy and he's doing a great job atm, im just not convinced that if the going gets tough he'll be able to be hard on the players 

[The Specky Forum Organiser 64,325]

Just now, GOAT said:

If we go through this entire month without dropping a single point, I'll change my name to Murty.  

Just gonna quote this...