Officialdom Conspiracy 2020/21?

[SeparateEntityMyArse 53,715]

For significant dodgy / dubious  and blatantly wrong decisions game changing in nature. And laws wrongly enforced type decisions...... Includes refs, matchday officials and Compliance Officer decisions and interventions.

***Post 1 will be updated after each game***

For: 6

Against: 17

 

Synopsis:

Game 1: Sheep away (Bobby Madden)

Decent performance by Madden as far as big decisions, less so standard ones. Stonewall red for Considine foul on Arfield. Would like to have seen several angles and more analysis of 2 incidents. Firstly Hayes (77 mins) running and looking at Goldson and smashing him with elbow/shoulder without looking at ball. And last minute tackle on Alfie in the box with penalty shouts made.

But nothing overly contentious 👍

Game 2: St Mirren home (Andrew Dallas)

Few St Mirren challenges that maybe warranted a yellow that wasn't given.

St Mirren penalty. Their player stretched into box to shield the ball. Kamara was clumsy by making any contact. Soft, but most would probably not argue with a foul outside the box, so Imo as right leg in the box then its a softish penalty.

1 in our favour, 0 against today

Game 3: St Johnstone home (Euan Anderson)

Not awarded penalty on Itten.

Red for tackle on Roofe. Still images make it look worse than it did from the 2nd camera angle, where the leading leg goes over Roofe not through him. But based on the rule when a player lunges in its still a red.

2 wrong decisions against us, 0 for.  

Game 4: Livi away (Nick Walsh)

Plenty time wasting, a booking for Morelos just because its him, no contentious decisions needing made.

0 for or against.

Game 5: Killie home (Clancy)

Standard Clancy performance. That of a wee prick.

No idea what Itten was booked for.  Blatant foul on Barker ignored (Barisic territory). Their forward blatantly grabs Goldson but not even spoke to. Time wasting allowed as it has been all season.

I'm going to say there was a possible penalty where the defender extended his arms from his body, not in natural position and making body bigger then got hit on elbow. Not sern enough to say yes though

0 for or against

Game 6: Hamilton away (Collum)

Cant criticise any of the yellows or the red but:

1. Our 1st goal imo was offside. As it comes off Roofes head Hagi is offside imo

Edit, came odd defender not Roofe

2. Penalty not given for push on Roofe. A CF is entitled to keep his hands out to protect his space. Thats not pushing or commiting a foul. He was shoved in the back as he went for the ball. 100% penalty.

0 for, 1 against.

Game 7: Dundee Utd (Clancy)

Zero protection offered by Clancy. Numerous bookable offences by Utd ignored. A terrible challenge leaving stud hole on Alfredo not even given as a foul. An obvious red simply ignored.

0 for, 1 against.

Game 8: Hivs (Don Robertson)

Offside goal given.

Porteous shape his arse and use his arm to obstruct Alfie in the last minute, that's a 2nd yellow and red for me.

Hanlon on Hagi is a deliberate raised elbow to the face. Imo a red.

3 against, arguably more

Game 9: Motherwell (Bobby Madden)

Shove in the back not shoulder to shoulder by Kamara. Soft, and their player anticipated and played for it, but I do think it was a foul so yeah penalty.

Both penalties given spot on based on the current rules.

0 against.

1 for us today.

Game 10: Ross County (Greg Aitken)

Player should have been red carded at the penalty. Clear goal scoring chance, foul given, there's clear contact but no attempt to genuinely play the ball. Harsh for the lad but by letter of law should have been a red.

0 for, 1 against.

Game 11: Scum (Beaton)

Very good refereeing performance. Let the game be about the players not him, carded rightly when necessary. 

Game 12: Livi (Walsh)

Nothing of note I can remember

Game 13: Killie (Dallas)

Stonewall penalty. No other big decisions 

Game 14: Hamilton (McLean)

8 nil thrashing, including blatant penalty, nothing contentious.

Game 15: Sheep (Walsh)

Missed blatant foul on Roofe for what should have been a penalty.

0 for, 1 against.

Game 16: Ross County (Beaton)

Nothing for ref to get involved in but dealing with a bit of name calling.

Game 17: Dundee Hivs (Mclean)

Blatant red card elbow by Morelos, only given a yellow. Huge break early in 1st half.

Foul on Goldson, arms wrapped round him and held, penalty wrongly not awarded.

Possible hand to ball by their defender around 70th minute but Arfield was quite close as he flicked it so a 50/50 one.

1 huge decision for, 1 against.

*** Compliance Officer retrospective red for Morelos***

Game 18: Motherwell (Don Robertson)

Missed handball in build up to Motherwell goal.

1 against

Game 19: St J (Walsh)

Deserved red card for O'Halloran. No overly big decisions of note.

0 for or against.

Game 20: Hivs (Collum)

4 contentious penalty shouts yesterday.

1. Tav. Imo he makes contact with their player's standing leg, the boy didn't bring him down. No pen 

2. Boyle (?). Tav chasing him in the box, Nisbet sees this and pushes Tav slightly off balance into Boyle creating the contact. No pen.

3. Hagi. His boot is high, but the ball is there to be won. He's not made the slightest contact with their player. Indirect free kick if anything, no penalty.

4. Porteous. IMHO the biggest penalty shout. He isn't fully in control, his leg is resting on the ball whilst his foot takes out Roofe. Slow mo shows clear penalty 

0 for, 1 against

Game 21: St Mirren (Alan Muir)

Elbow on Goldson debatable possible red. Arguably a yellow, but if the CO retrospectively acted in it (😂😂 I know, I know) it wouldn't shock anyone.

0 for, 0 against * - asterisk for the Goldson one 😂

Game 22: Scum (Madden)

1.  Missed barge by thumb on Roofe should have been a penalty all day long.

2.  Duffy tackle on Kent a red not yellow.

Lennon full of excuses that red card shouldn't have been awarded to Bitton. It should, it was one big call Madden got correct.

Brown play acting is simulation, I'm gonna check the rules but morally he should face retrospective CO action. 

Game 23: Sheep (Beaton)

Penalty for Rangers and red card fully justified. Main wrongly not red carded for foul on Borna.

1 against

Game 24: Motherwell

Itten goal marginally offside. One for.

Motherwell goal the man at back post ran towards ball and goal from offside position arguably becoming actively involved in play. Harsh as didn't touch ball or get in way of keeper so not including in scores.

1 for, 0 against

Game 25: Ross County (Anderson)

Inconclusive whether penalty awarded occurred outside or on edge of box. No scores.

Game 26: Hivs (Clancy)

Missed Morelos incident. *Retrospectively deemed a red so one in our favour.

Missed similar McGregor incident. Equal foul and actually committed after throwing Kamara to ground. One against.

Porteous typically dangerous but not quite meritting reds.

1 for, 1 against.

Game 27: St J (Munro)

Roofe probable red card.

1 decision for 

***retrospective red***

Game 28: Hamilton (Madden)

Nothing of note.

Game 29: St J (Robertson)

Penalty for challenge in Tav not given.

Nonsense claims over a challenge by Balogun that was outside the box that somehow ST J were robbed. Pish.

1 against us.

Game 30: Dundee Utd (Walsh)

Nothing to talk of.

Game 31: Livi (Beaton)

 

Completed fixtures:

Game 1: Bobby Madden

Game 2: Andrew Dallas

Game 3: Euan Anderson

Game 4: Nick Walsh

Game 5: wanker Nancy Clancy 

Game 6: Collum

Game 7: wanker Nancy Clancy

Game 8: Don Robertson 

Game 9: Bobby Madden

Game 10: Greg Aitken

Game 11: Beaton

Game 12: Walsh

Game 13: Dallas 

Game 14: McLean

Game 15: Walsh

Game 16: Beaton

Game 17: McLean 

Game 18: Don Robertson

Game 19: Walsh

Game 20: Collum

Game 21: Muir

Game 22: Madden

Game 23: Beaton 

Game 24: Robertson

Game 25: Anderson

Game 26: wanker Nancy Clancy

Gsme 27: Munro

Game 28: Madden 

Game 29: Robertson 

Game 30: Walsh

Game 31: Beaton.

[EMRFC 4,780]

Bobby Madden was surprisingly good yesterday I thought 

[blueballss 2,969]

3000 pager by May 2021, if not before

[.Williamson. 82,176]

Fuck sake

[SeparateEntityMyArse 53,715]

3 minutes ago, blueballss said:

3000 pager by December, if not before

Amended, agreed.

[SeparateEntityMyArse 53,715]

Just now, .Williamson. said:

Fuck sake

Good content, thanks for sharing.

[The Godfather 71,874]

3 minutes ago, SeparateEntityMyArse said:

Good content, thanks for sharing.

Said no woman after a load shoots down her nose 

[superallysbears 7,580]

Brilliant, can see me posting alot on this thread 

[dummiesoot 16,005]

5 minutes ago, .Williamson. said:

Fuck sake

You came in to post that, well done very constructive.

[King Jela 20,361]

Delibrately decided against giving us a stonewall penalty, he unserstood Clancy's message loud and clear through the week. 

[Clemdog 39,389]

To think we used to sing 'Its a Conspiracy'...

[.Williamson. 82,176]

4 minutes ago, dummiesoot said:

You came in to post that, well done very constructive.

Give over 

[.Williamson. 82,176]

A thread literally rating refereeing performances in each individual game 

Horrendously cringy 

[Jamie0202 12,272]

2 minutes ago, GabrielTomato said:

To think we used to sing 'Its a Conspiracy'...

Have you seen the shit that's gone on in the past few years? I fully support this thread.

That said I thought Madden was decent yesterday and was pretty anonymous (a good thing for a ref) except the stone wall red card.

[AlbertzLoyalRSC 18,070]

4 minutes ago, GabrielTomato said:

To think we used to sing 'Its a Conspiracy'...

Sorry it's OT, but what does honky tonk mean mate? 

[British_Empire 9,648]

27 minutes ago, EMRFC said:

Bobby Madden was surprisingly good yesterday I thought 

Same tbh. Surprisingly. 

Also, I don't know If I'm quite there yet with the "referee's are cheats" theory (even though the comments midweek were worrying)

I'm not ruling it out. The corruption in Scottish football is blatant and in front of our faces, so why not assume it stretches to ref's too.

They're certainly incompetent, at best. Perhaps being too kind there.

[Jamie0202 12,272]

1 minute ago, AlbertzLoyalRSC said:

Sorry it's OT, but what does honky tonk mean mate? 

Ask Jagger mate.

[ForeverAndEver 71,467]

Not seen/can’t remember the Hayes one, or the Ferguson one on Goldson people were talking about.

Don’t think it was a penalty either tbh

[AlbertzLoyalRSC 18,070]

1 minute ago, Jamie0202 said:

Ask Jagger mate.

What's @Brian Fantana got to do with it?

[SeparateEntityMyArse 53,715]

9 minutes ago, .Williamson. said:

A thread literally rating refereeing performances in each individual game 

Horrendously cringy 

Its been done the last few years, and I said I'd repeat this year. Sort of stemmed from Beaton in the game v Hivs, highlighted significant anomalies in how we are treated. The clancy scum game on the 29th Dec should embarrass you when questioning any detailed look into the decisions wrongly given in our games, especially against.

Strange it hasn't but each to their own. 

Feel free to comment as the season progresses. In previous seasons those with similar views to you either had their 👀 opened or disappeared as the argument was overwhelmingly evidenced against them.

Hope we get through this season and the thread is redundant as we're treated fairly. Do you agree and think we will be?

[gmcf 34,152]

Aye quite right , some of the decisions the last few years have been diabolical and worthy of keeping tabs on . 

Pretty solid performance from Madden yesterday , got all the big calls right .

[SeparateEntityMyArse 53,715]

10 minutes ago, ForeverAndEver said:

Not seen/can’t remember the Hayes one, or the Ferguson one on Goldson people were talking about.

Don’t think it was a penalty either tbh

Re the pen claim, how many times or angles you seen it from? 1 angle I've seen and few repeats. That's why I'm not ssying it was a pen, contact was defo made on him without getting the ball.

I'll try tomorrow to get the Hayes one up. Not a red i don't think, though again little analysis by the commentators, but it looked naughty.

[SeparateEntityMyArse 53,715]

20 minutes ago, .Williamson. said:

A thread literally rating refereeing performances in each individual game 

Horrendously cringy 

What was his rating given as?  

Why is that contentious or an issue if accurate?

[The Hammer 11 2,575]

This is a redneck

[BridgeIsBlue 66,606]

The penalty for Morelos was almost a carbon copy of the one they got a couple of year ago for McLean.