I'm still leaning towards Goram but this is the post of the thread. Goram was genuinely extraordinary and a world-class keeper on his day and people shouldn't forget it. Comparing peak to peak, I'd still say Goram was better - but I think you're probably right that if you compare them over their whole careers rather than say, McGregor 20/21 v Goram 92/93, the case for McGregor might well be stronger.
Folk getting agitated about who our best goalie of all time is 😂
Goram was phenomenal. Even more so given his boozing and general condition. Flying pig wasn’t meant to be complimentary.
In his peak season for us I think he was the best goalie in the world and at a time when Schmeichel was at his peak that is saying a lot.
But McGregor has done it for longer and more often than Goram did now, and I think he still has more in him. He has just gotten better and better. Goram deteriorated quite significantly.
Is Peak Allan McGregor a better goalkeeper than peak Andy Goram? That’s a very hard call to make. But has McGregor been a better goalkeeper over the piece? I don’t think that’s in doubt anymore.
if there was a poll today of Rangers best ever goalkeeper I would vote McGregor by a baw hair