Player - was good at his job, one of lads - the 'cheeky chappie'. Always thought no matter what happened Mccoist could at anytime score. Doesn't mean he is morally sound or would make a good manager. Fond memories of the player for me. TV personality - never watched it much but he seemed too... easy going (immature?). Couldn't see Warburton etc be like Mccoist. Manager - got results yes. Play on the park, tactics etc poor. Too again easy going. Seemed out his depth and towards the end a bit 'unwell - run down' look - couldn't handle the pressure - ie Ramsden cup final? No fond memories of the manager. Disasterous but not fatal. Post-manager - big issue I think with most fans - the morality of the contract gardening leave. Poor decision my Mccoist for me. Seems to have done irreparable damage to his status with some. Not so with me though I think he should have done the mature thing (is he?) and not taken it. So Ally Mccoist is a solid number 2 for me.