Cuellar (2007-2008) vs Bougherra (2008-Present)

[Goianegra]

Noticed a wee bit of debate on here lately

[simplythebest]

Cuellar.

[Gazzas_Flute]

Madjid has done well for us domestically but Cuellar never stepped a foot wrong both domestically and in Europe.

Cuellar for me.

[BLUENIZ]

Carlos. No question.IMO.

[chris_glasgow]

Cuellar I dont hink I have ever heard a commentator almost lost for words how well Cuellar was in Lisbon and Florence than Beglin was a swear he was almost creaming himself

[GOAT]

I can't remember who it was against, but Cuellar had ONE bad game. Now one bad game in 60 odds says it all.

[lidorfc]

bougherra has done it in the spl, cuellar done it in europe and spl, cuellar for me.

[BryanRfc]

Cuellar

[maxwellrfc]

cuellar

[maxwellrfc]

double post

[the goal machine]

Cuellar

Just a thought, to the people who said Cuellar has done it in Europe as an argument, Bougherra's not exactly had that chance.

[RangersKenny]

King Carlos - dont get me wrong, Boogie is tremendous, however we all seen the heartache that was caused by Carlos' departure and im pretty sure it wouldn't be as bad if Boogie decided to jump ship.

Possibly a good thing for us that Carlos hasn't exactly set the heather on fire down in England, cos possibly that may make Boogie realise his level and stay where he is.

Challenge in Europe for him next year should be good, i think he will be an outstanding player for us in CL if we reach it.

[BoltonLoyal]

Carlos for me as well, i know loads of people didn't like how he went, but from a purely footballing perspective the guy oozed class from day one. Awesome defender.

[CF5LOYAL]

Cuellar, some of performances in Europe were breath taking. Also he went down south to the tea 3rd in the EPL and hasn't looked out of place, even when being played at right back sometimes.

Cuellar is a top class defender but Bougherra has the potential to be as good, he is great in the air, grea pace andhis distribution is excellent.

[McBoyd]

Cuellar, no questions asked.

[rangers4eva]

Cuellar

[feda16]

i think next season (providing we qualify for CL) will be the season to judge Bougherra. Until then its an unfair to judge them against each other as Bougherra never played in europe

[feda16]

i think next season (providing we qualify for CL) will be the season to judge Bougherra. Until then its an unfair to judge them against each other as Bougherra never played in europe

[The Hammer 11]

Bougherra he is better going forward imo it's hard to judge between the two as they are two different types of defender

[CooperSF]

Cuellar

[CooperSF]

Cuellar

[ManchestGer]

cuellar

[Eckzander7]

cuellar no question

[BlueSuedeSambas]

Who voted Bougherra

[alstone]

cuellar was fantastic for us

a total cunt though - going on abotu staying for rangers for the rest of his career and then fucks off to the premiership the next day