Jump to content

Rate Rangers Players out of 10 - with a twist


nottsbear

Recommended Posts

The Boyd disscusions have me thinking: are we behind just now becuase of a lack of effort, quality or both? some people get unfairly called Boyd supporters etc for backing his ability. I thought maybe it would be interesting to see how people rate the players out of ten for A quality and B commitment/effort

rate as many or as few as you like!

:gerbad:

My Thoughts..................

McGregor 8 9

Alexander 7 8

Broadfoot 5 9

Whittaker 5 7

Papac 7 7

Weir 6 10

Bougherra 8 7

Ferguson 8 10

Davis 7 6

Mendes 8 8

Fleck 7 7

McCulloch 5 8

Dailly 5 8

Thomson 7 7

Edu 5 6

Aaron 7 7

Beasley 5 7

Lafferty 7 7

Miller 5 8

Naismith 6 6

Boyd 8 2

Novo 7 10

:gerbad:

Link to post
Share on other sites

:gerbad:

The Boyd disscusions have me thinking: are we behind just now becuase of a lack of effort, quality or both? some people get unfairly called Boyd supporters etc for backing his ability. I thought maybe it would be interesting to see how people rate the players out of ten for A quality and B commitment/effort

rate as many or as few as you like!

:gerbad:

My Thoughts..................

McGregor 8 9

Alexander 7 8

Broadfoot 5 9

Whittaker 5 7

Papac 7 7

Weir 6 10

Bougherra 8 7

Ferguson 8 10

Davis 7 6

Mendes 8 8

Fleck 7 7

McCulloch 5 8

Dailly 5 8

Thomson 7 7

Edu 5 6

Aaron 7 7

Beasley 5 7

Lafferty 7 7

Miller 5 8

Naismith 6 6

Boyd 8 2

Novo 7 10

:gerbad:

Link to post
Share on other sites

The Boyd disscusions have me thinking: are we behind just now becuase of a lack of effort, quality or both? some people get unfairly called Boyd supporters etc for backing his ability. I thought maybe it would be interesting to see how people rate the players out of ten for A quality and B commitment/effort

rate as many or as few as you like!

:gerbad:

My Thoughts..................

McGregor 8 9

Alexander 7 8

Broadfoot 5 9

Whittaker 5 7

Papac 7 7

Weir 6 10

Bougherra 8 7

Ferguson 8 10

Davis 7 6

Mendes 8 8

Fleck 7 7

McCulloch 5 8

Dailly 5 8

Thomson 7 7

Edu 5 6

Aaron 7 7

Beasley 5 7

Lafferty 7 7

Miller 5 8

Naismith 6 6

Boyd 8 2

Novo 7 10

:gerbad:

Very interesting concept!

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'll play for a little bit of fun.

McGregor 8 9

Alexander 7 8

Broadfoot 5 9

Whittaker 6.5 7

Papac 6 7

Weir 6 9

Bougherra 8 9

Ferguson 7 9

Davis 8 7

Mendes 8 7

Fleck 8 7

McCulloch 5 8

Dailly 3 7

Thomson 8 9

Edu 6.5 6

Aaron 7 7

Beasley 7 7

Lafferty 7 8.5

Miller 5 7

Naismith 6 6

Boyd 6.5 4

Novo 7 9

Link to post
Share on other sites

The Boyd disscusions have me thinking: are we behind just now becuase of a lack of effort, quality or both? some people get unfairly called Boyd supporters etc for backing his ability. I thought maybe it would be interesting to see how people rate the players out of ten for A quality and B commitment/effort

rate as many or as few as you like!

:gerbad:

My Thoughts..................

McGregor 8 9

Alexander 7 8

Broadfoot 3 7

Whittaker 8 7

Papac 6 6

Weir 6 9

Bougherra 8 7

Ferguson 7 7

Davis 8 6

Mendes 8 8

Fleck 7 7

McCulloch 5 8

Dailly 5 8

Thomson 7 9

Edu 7 6

Aaron 7 7

Beasley 5 7

Lafferty 8 9

Miller 7 9

Naismith 6 6

Boyd 3 2

Novo 6 10

:gerbad:

My scores.

Good thread, very interesting :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

McGregor 7 8

Alexander 7 8

Broadfoot 3 8

Whittaker 7 6

Papac 6 7

Weir 6 9

Bougherra 9 7

Ferguson 8 6

Davis 7 7

Mendes 9 7

Fleck 7 8

McCulloch 4 6

Dailly 4 7

Thomson 7 9

Edu 6 6

Aaron 8 7

Beasley 7 7

Lafferty 7 9

Miller 5 8

Naismith 6 6

Boyd 2 -5

Novo 7 10

Link to post
Share on other sites

McGregor 8 8

Alexander 7 8

Broadfoot 6 9

Whittaker 7 7

Papac 7 8

Weir 7 9

Bougherra 8 8

Ferguson 6 6

Davis 8 8

Mendes 8 8

Fleck 7 7

McCulloch 4 6

Dailly 5 7

Thomson 8 9

Edu 6 6

Aaron 8 7

Beasley 7 7

Lafferty 8 8

Miller 4 7

Naismith 6 6

Boyd 6 1

Novo 7 11

Link to post
Share on other sites

McGregor 9 8

Alexander 7 8

Broadfoot 7 8

Whittaker 7 7

Papac 8 9

Weir 7 10

Bougherra 8 ? (tell you in july!)

Ferguson 6 6 (used to be 10/10)

Davis 7 7

Mendes 8 7

Fleck 7 7

McCulloch 6 8

Dailly 5 8

Thomson 9 9

Edu 7 7

Aaron 7 7

Beasley 6 6

Lafferty 7 9

Miller 6 9

Naismith 7 7

Boyd 8 8

Novo 7 10

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...