Jump to content

Value of our best XI v theirs


Recommended Posts

Mcgregor - 8 Forster - 3

whittaker - 2.5 cha du ri - 1.5

Weir - 0 Mastehfuifhovic - 3

Bougie - 6 loovens - 2

papac - 2.5 izig ???? - 1.5

weiss - 4 maloney - 3

davis - 6 Ledley - 4

edu - 3 juerez - 3

Mculloch - 1.5 stokes - 2.5

Naismith - 4 samaras - 1.5

miller - 1.5 hooper - 3

Total - 39 Million Total - 28 Million

Link to post
Share on other sites

This had more space when i wrote it out lol . you get the point tho

Mcgregor - 8 Forster - 3

whittaker - 2.5 cha du ri - 1.5

Weir - 0 Mastehfuifhovic - 3

Bougie - 6 loovens - 2

papac - 2.5 izig ???? - 1.5

weiss - 4 maloney - 3

davis - 6 Ledley - 4

edu - 3 juerez - 3

Mculloch - 1.5 stokes - 2.5

Naismith - 4 samaras - 1.5

miller - 1.5 hooper - 3

Total - 39 Million Total - 28 Million

Link to post
Share on other sites

Allan McGregor (28) - £6 million

Steven Whittaker (26) - £2 million

Sasa Papac (30) - £750,000

Madjid Bougherra (28) - £5 million

David Weir (40) - £0

Lee McCulloch (32) - £500,000

Steven Naismith (24) - £2.5 million

Steven Davis (25) - £5 million

Kenny Miller (30) - £3 million

Nikica Jelavic (25) - £4 million

Vladimir Weiss (20) - £4.5 million

vs

Fraser Forster (22) - £1.5 million

Cha Du-Ri (30) - £750,000

Emilio Izaguirre (24) - £750,000

Daniel Majstorovic (33) - £500,000

Glenn Loovens (26) - £2 million

Scott Brown (25) - £4 million

Efrain Juarez (22) - £4 million

Joe Ledley (23) - £4.5 million

Anthony Stokes (22) - £2.5 million

Gary Hooper (22) - £2.5 million

Shaun Maloney (27) - £3.5 million

Obviously though Weiss and Forster are on loan so their valuations don't really matter.

In terms of sale value there's not too much between the teams but I'd say we edge it as more of our players are proven in British football at the moment.

As for the actual values, remember a player is only worth as much as someone is willing to pay for him or a club is willing to sell him for. All these people saying McGregor's worth £10 million + are fooling themselves if they think we'd actually ever get that much for him. Sure Craig Gordon went for £8 million, but then there was more money being spent in the game back then.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Anyone want to have a go? Their value if some team was to come in and want to buy.

Rangers

McGregor 6m 9-12m

Whittaker 2m agreed

Weir 0.5m 0

Bougherra 5m agreed

Papac 1m 1.5-2m

Naismith 2.5m 5m if he keep the form up

Edu 3m 1m top (day dreams too much)

Davis 3.5m 6-8m

Weiss 4m (not ours but 3m)

Miller 2m 1m (free in summer)

Jelavic 4m 2.5m (we got stung but still a good player though)

Total 33.5m

I know Weiss is not our player but thats not the point in this post.

Thimmy

?? Anyone want to have a go?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Prices today: the top price i think we could get

McGregor £11m

Whittaker £3.5m

Weir £150k

Bougherra £10m

Papac £2.5m

Naismith £4.2m

Edu £3.5m

Davis £8.5m

Weiss £8.5m

Miller £4m

Jelavic £5.5m

However if it was in the English Prem

McGregor £18m

Whittaker £5.5m

Weir £250k

Bougherra £17m

Papac £6.5m

Naismith £8.2m

Edu £7.2m

Davis £12.5m

Weiss £13.5m

Miller £7m

Jelavic £7.5m

Link to post
Share on other sites

Mcgregor - 9million, probably the most we could get for him, probably worth more though.

Whittaker - 1.5million - cant see anyone paying over that for him

Weir - 0, No one would pay for a 40 year player.

Boogie - 9million - African player of the year, champions league team of the week twice this year, not getting him cheap.

Papac - 1.5million - reliable, but seems to be underrated.

Naismith - 4million - if he keeps his current form, we could get this easily.

Edu - 2million - prospect for the future maybe

Davis - 6.5million - proven midfielder with EPL and European experience.

Weiss - 7million - Man City wouldnt take a penny less

Miller - 2million - getting on a bit but in top form

Jelavic - 8million - we payed 4million for him in the summer, it would take a bid this high for us to consider selling him a few months later.

Total - 50.5million.... i think

Dont rate their side at all, 20million for the lot if your lucky.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Allan McGregor - £6.5m

Steven Whittaker - £2.5m

Sasa Papac - £1.5m

Madjid Bougherra - £7.5m

David Weir - £0

Lee McCulloch - £750k

Steven Naismith - £2.5m

Steven Davis - £5.75m

Kenny Miller - £3m

Nikica Jelavic - £4.25m

Vladimir Weiss - £4m

Total: £38.25m

vs

Fraser Forster - £1.5m

Cha Du-Ri - £1m

Emilio Izaguirre - £1.25m

Daniel Majstorovic - £600k

Glenn Loovens - £1.75m

Scott Brown - £5m

Efrain Juarez - £3.5m

Joe Ledley - £4.25m

Anthony Stokes - £2m

Gary Hooper - £2m

Shaun Maloney - £4m

Total: £26.85m

These were quick evaluations, may have been a little biased but if Hutton and Cuellar and go for more than £7m then Bougie and Greegs can <cr>

Link to post
Share on other sites

Allan McGregor - £6.5m

Steven Whittaker - £750k

Sasa Papac - £1.5m

Madjid Bougherra - £4m

David Weir - £0

Lee McCulloch - £400k

Steven Naismith - £1.75m

Steven Davis - £2.75m

Kenny Miller - £500k (given contract status)

Nikica Jelavic - £2.5m

Vladimir Weiss - N/A

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Upcoming Events

    • 28 April 2024 11:30 Until 13:30
      0  
      St Mirren v Rangers
      The SMiSA Stadium
      Scottish Premiership
      Live on Sky Sports Main Event and Sky Sports Football
×
×
  • Create New...