POLL - Steven Naismith versus Andy Carroll

[deleteduser1 169]

Assuming both players were fully fit and available for selection and you had to choose just one of them to play in the biggest match of your ( fictional ) managerial career - which of the two players would you choose and why?

Try to be objective in your vote/answer.

I would choose Steven Naismith every day of the week and twice on Sundays simply because I believe he is a far far better player than the Englishman.

[Clemdog 39,389]

It isn't a very fair poll.

[gunslinger 270]

It isn't a very fair poll.

especially as it doesn't work.

[stefmartin16 121]

This poll is rubbish. You are cheating.

[Getstiffed 8,863]

I wouldnt trust Andy Carrol to paint my fence mate.

[Clemdog 39,389]

especially as it doesn't work.

I see what you did there.

[LeeWallaceRFC 3,920]

You need to fix the pool first, lol.

[deleteduser1 169]

You need to fix the pool first, lol.

Sorry guys

Fixed

[Johnstone Burgh 1,637]

Naisy without a doubt. He can actually put a ball in a net, with his foot!

[Jimbo. 952]

Andy Carroll would knock his cunt in.

[Monty1872 45]

Whoever voted for the donkey MUST be taking the piss

[twigrfc1 1]

I wouldnt trust Andy Carrol to paint my fence mate.

Haha says it all

[deleteduser1 169]

Whoever voted for the donkey MUST be taking the piss

Obviously Andy Carroll must be registered on RM?

[deleteduser1 169]

Andy Carroll would knock his cunt in.

He would need to catch wee Naisy first

[Smile 26,600]

Andy Carroll has to be one of the worst strikers I've ever seen for the price, he's an abysmal footballer.

Also he looks like a Dirty Taig.

[supermac 115]

Injured Naisy before Carroll

[cameron1873 511]

I wonder who is gonna win this

[gazza27 15,283]

what a terrible thread

[deleteduser1 169]

what a terrible thread

Do you have an opinion on the topic or not?

[TBagalag 721]

I'd probably pick myself over Carroll, not only is he shite, but he has a fuckin ponytail and jumps like he's been nailed to the floor. Makes Crouch look like Messi.

[deleteduser1 169]

I'd probably pick myself over Carroll, not only is he shite, but he has a fuckin ponytail and jumps like he's been nailed to the floor. Makes Crouch look like Messi.

Nailed to the floor.

Vote is 20 for Naisy and 1 for Carroll so far.

[BELFAST FINEST 7]

if caroll worth 35 million mucn naisy worth? still rather have naisy...

[G.E.C. 18,751]

I'm only guessing this thread was made because we like the long ball, and both are good in the air.

[deleteduser1 169]

I wonder who is gonna win this

OK , I admit I would have been very surprised if our Naisy didn't come out on top of the poll by a fair margin mate but I wanted to highlight the value of Naisy to our club and point out the unfairness of the ( scandalous )valuation that has been placed on Steven by Fulham just recently.

We need to let those that would take advantage of our financial plight know Steven Naismith is a better player than £35 million rated Carroll - and we know it - and we are well aware of those clubs , including Fulham , aiming to rip us off during the most difficult time in our clubs history.

[Amac9 2,060]

Naismith.

Carroll is gash!