Cheers for a good reply, I realise I don't necessarily deserve one for some very deep sea fishing. I would 100% agree that whatever form Rangers continue in, it should be in the 3rd division. 100%. While there were a number of decisions made that led to the situation where Whyte was able to take control and then run your club into the ground, I would again agree that the only punishment that could be meted out was the deduction of 10 points. It's important that everyone (us, the other clubs and you, Rangers) remembers this. Things have gone disastrously wrong at Rangers and have done for years. Who knows what is still to come out in the wash. I'm imaging there'll be some truth in the rumours about false accounting and other issues that were hinted at a couple of days ago. It's interesting though that you say there are only a few things that the club were demonstrably guilty of. It's true that so far there are only a few things. What is looking increasingly likely though is that there will be much, much more that the 'oldco' will be found guilty of, but that will likely take years to get to the bottom of. I'd offer that it's in everyone's best interest that from a footballing point of view a line is drawn in the sand now and a decision made on how to proceed. It's tricky, but the SPL has been thrown a lifeline on it's decision making as Rangers have reached the stage of liquidation and must apply for a transfer of the league share. The other clubs would be mental to allow Rangers in and have revelation upon revelation, be forced to deal with punishment after punishment and draw the whole sorry mess out. Starting again in the 3rd division as a new entity gives everyone an out. Rangers (should) know there will be no further punishments and the SPL can get on with normal business without a ridiculous sideshow. Personally I think that's enough punishment, and technically, that's only one punishment. I'll not try and insult your intelligence though, if the people in charge of Rangers don't sort the mess out and the club goes, I won't shed a tear. We all know though that Rangers will continue somehow, in some form and I genuinely don't know of anyone who actually wants your club eradicated.