The squad is laughable, Defoe is a surprise but he deserves to be in there, he's scored 17 goals this season and hardly played! Carroll shouldn't be in there, hes had 120 minutes of good football this season compared to Crouch and Holt who have double figures at least for the season! Merson on SSN has just summed up that pick - "Carroll has had a good month, but the season started in August". If anyone can explain how Stuart Downing manages to get in that squad then please go ahead, he's awful, £20 million down the drain. Players picked on reputation rather than form, what a shambles.