The Ultimate (Who we want to go in the Jan Sales) Poll Results

[Bluepeter9 5,167]

1 Davis 1 0.50%

2 Bougherra 2 1.00%

3 Mendes 2 1.00%

4 Thomson 3 1.50%

5 Niguez 3 1.50%

6 Alexander 4 2.00%

7 Papac 4 2.00%

8 Edu 5 2.50%

9 Naismith 6 3.00%

10 Novo 7 3.50%

11 Boyd 7 3.50%

12 Lafferty 9 4.50%

13 Miller 9 4.50%

14 McGregor 16 8.00%

15 Ferguson 28 14.00%

16 Broadfoot 32 16.00%

17 Whittaker 38 19.00%

18 Weir 55 27.50%

19 Steven Smith 87 43.50%

20 DeBeasley 91 45.50%

21 Velicka 96 48.00%

22 Graham Smith 97 48.50%

23 Burke 123 61.50%

24 Hemdani 160 80.00%

25 Adam 164 82.00%

26 McCollough 172 86.00%

27 Darchiville 178 89.00%

28 Dailly 187 93.50%

Sample size 200

The bottom 8 - 10 are the ones this poll participants would get rid of! and no real surprises (IMHO)

First Team would be : (Assuming fit and based on popularity) Novo and Boyd had same number of votes - put Boyd in as Naismith was in)!

Alexander

Papac

Bougherra

Broadfoot

Whittaker

Davis

Mendes

Thomson

Niguez

Naismith

Boyd

Bench from: - (Plus U21 players)

McGregor

Weir

Edu

Lafferty

Miller

Novo

Ferguson

Surpises (In my view) -

13 people didn't vote to get rid of Dailly!

2 voted for Mendes

Harsh on Graham Smith

Marginally more people want Adam to stay than McCollough

[jrms999 22]

Good poll

[Craigy 0]

Harsh on Graeme Smith? The guys taking money for nothing and we have Alexander and McGregor.

[NOLUWDC 1]

I quite like that team.

[papaguy51 912]

1 Davis 1 0.50%

2 Bougherra 2 1.00%

3 Mendes 2 1.00%

4 Thomson 3 1.50%

5 Niguez 3 1.50%

6 Alexander 4 2.00%

7 Papac 4 2.00%

8 Edu 5 2.50%

9 Naismith 6 3.00%

I'd love to meet the people who voted for this selection of players

[Fremlin 0]

1 Davis 1 0.50%

2 Bougherra 2 1.00%

3 Mendes 2 1.00%

4 Thomson 3 1.50%

5 Niguez 3 1.50%

6 Alexander 4 2.00%

7 Papac 4 2.00%

8 Edu 5 2.50%

9 Naismith 6 3.00%

10 Novo 7 3.50%

11 Boyd 7 3.50%

12 Lafferty 9 4.50%

13 Miller 9 4.50%

14 McGregor 16 8.00%

15 Ferguson 28 14.00%

16 Broadfoot 32 16.00%

17 Whittaker 38 19.00%

18 Weir 55 27.50%

19 Steven Smith 87 43.50%

20 DeBeasley 91 45.50%

21 Velicka 96 48.00%

22 Graham Smith 97 48.50%

23 Burke 123 61.50%

24 Hemdani 160 80.00%

25 Adam 164 82.00%

26 McCollough 172 86.00%

27 Darchiville 178 89.00%

28 Dailly 187 93.50%

I reckon you could easily lose everyone from 20 down and you wouldn't even notice the difference.

[Bluepeter9 5,167]

1 Davis 1 0.50%

2 Bougherra 2 1.00%

3 Mendes 2 1.00%

4 Thomson 3 1.50%

5 Niguez 3 1.50%

6 Alexander 4 2.00%

7 Papac 4 2.00%

8 Edu 5 2.50%

9 Naismith 6 3.00%

I'd love to meet the people who voted for this selection of players

Well I votes for Niguez but only based on the fact I dont like loan players - but if as you say elsewhere we have a fixed fee if we want to keep him - I probably wouldn't have.

[JohnGalbraith 0]

Harsh on Graeme Smith? The guys taking money for nothing and we have Alexander and McGregor.

If you want to compete in European competition you need to have 3 registered senior goalkeepers.

Smith is one of few senior goalies who is quite happy being 3rd choice and never playing, at the end of the day - someone's got to do it.

[ManchestGer 347]

No surprise Dailly was voted for most. Definitely true about 20 down, wouldnt notice if they were gone

[Mark. 69]

1 Davis 1 0.50%

2 Bougherra 2 1.00%

3 Mendes 2 1.00%

4 Thomson 3 1.50%

5 Niguez 3 1.50%

6 Alexander 4 2.00%

7 Papac 4 2.00%

8 Edu 5 2.50%

9 Naismith 6 3.00%

I'd love to meet the people who voted for this selection of players

Timmy lhurkers

[J-Maestro 11,271]

Why do people not understand the concept of a 3rd choice keeper?

[JohnGalbraith 0]

Why do people not understand the concept of a 3rd choice keeper?

No idea. I've said it on here about 50 times when people rattle thier gums about showing G.Smith the door.

[shnollyRFC 0]

How can people justify voting for big Lee after his performance on Saturday?!?

[TexasGers 96]

Why do people not understand the concept of a 3rd choice keeper?

No idea. I've said it on here about 50 times when people rattle thier gums about showing G.Smith the door.

Right, and it's not like he's on a 30,000 a week deal or anything. Graeme Smith is the least of our worries.

[Scott-RFC 308]

McCollough

[MikeBlue 136]

Why do people not understand the concept of a 3rd choice keeper?

Indeed - main keeper gets injured - so we don't have a keeper on the bench? They do get sent off every so often.

EDIT - but harsh on Miller IMO

[Bluepeter9 5,167]

Why do people not understand the concept of a 3rd choice keeper?

Indeed - main keeper gets injured - so we don't have a keeper on the bench? They do get sent off every so often.

EDIT - but harsh on Miller IMO

In some ways I was suprised only 9 voted for Miller to go - I would take that as an endorsement of his general acceptance as good for the team.

[blueballss 2,972]

1 Davis 1 0.50%

2 Bougherra 2 1.00%

3 Mendes 2 1.00%

4 Thomson 3 1.50%

5 Niguez 3 1.50%

6 Alexander 4 2.00%

7 Papac 4 2.00%

8 Edu 5 2.50%

9 Naismith 6 3.00%

I'd love to meet the people who voted for this selection of players

:beer2:

WTF

[docspiderman 1,242]

Get rid of 16 to 28 would be my preference and then we could easily up the standard of our squad by using the wages saved to buy a quality right back, central defender and a decent left midfield option.

[Nikke 0]

Harsh on Graeme Smith? The guys taking money for nothing and we have Alexander and McGregor.

Most clubs have three goalkeepers in their squads (first team and reserves combined).

Apparently they don´t consider Robinson good enough for first team football just yet.

[jhempl10 0]

What is interesting here is that no one is creaming themselves for John Fleck! I can't see his name mentioned anywhere.

[Bluepeter9 5,167]

What is interesting here is that no one is creaming themselves for John Fleck! I can't see his name mentioned anywhere.

I made the vote on First team squad only - while he gets to sit on the bench he is not in the actual first team squad - nor are any of the reserve team youth. Hence why Fleck is not on the list.

[jhempl10 0]

What is interesting here is that no one is creaming themselves for John Fleck! I can't see his name mentioned anywhere.

I made the vote on First team squad only - while he gets to sit on the bench he is not in the actual first team squad - nor are any of the reserve team youth. Hence why Fleck is not on the list.

Fair enough but I don't think Aaron Niguez with one subsititue appearance to his name is really a 1st team squad member... so is he not a youth warming the bench?

[Bazza 21]

How can people justify voting for big Lee after his performance on Saturday?!?

And him being able to play two positions too!!

[Bluepeter9 5,167]

What is interesting here is that no one is creaming themselves for John Fleck! I can't see his name mentioned anywhere.

I made the vote on First team squad only - while he gets to sit on the bench he is not in the actual first team squad - nor are any of the reserve team youth. Hence why Fleck is not on the list.

Fair enough but I don't think Aaron Niguez with one subsititue appearance to his name is really a 1st team squad member... so is he not a youth warming the bench?

I got the first team squad list from rangers.co.uk - so they treat him as a 1st team player - and the others as not. <_<