And Im sure the pundits have valuable insight into the game, however we are talking specifically a panel that ( based on its normal make up) has never made the transition to coaching or management, surely they would have more credibility if you have been successful yourself. It is as is often pointed out, easy to snipe from the sidelines when you are free of being judged yourself. poor CV compared to who? Theres or some of the other linked names.
The show is infotainment, I get that, however the make up of employees with a Celtic bent tends to steer the discussion in a rather comic book style. Theres no desire for serious comment just parody and one upmanship but then Jock football is just there for comedy value anyway.
All of which is an opinion.