I always wondered what would happen...

[disgruntled_bear 157]

If the boot was on the other foot.

We had Barry Ferguson vs PLG and we all know how that finished.

Now we have our greatest rivals in the same boat with McGeady vs WGS, i just wonder if the outcome will be the same!

[McBoyd 355]

If the boot was on the other foot.

We had Barry Ferguson vs PLG and we all know how that finished.

Now we our greatest rivals in the same boat with McGeady vs WGS, i just wonder if the outcome will be the same!

Hmm not quite the same is it, he hasn't stripped McGayday of captaincy has he?

[disgruntled_bear 157]

If the boot was on the other foot.

We had Barry Ferguson vs PLG and we all know how that finished.

Now we our greatest rivals in the same boat with McGeady vs WGS, i just wonder if the outcome will be the same!

Hmm not quite the same is it, he hasn't stripped McGayday of captaincy has he?

He's fined and suspended him for 2weeks, meaning he misses the OLDFIRM match.

McGeady is there equivalent of Ferguson, he's come through the youth ranks/fan and a fans favourite.

[James_Dean 0]

It isn't really the same. McGeady hasn't been at Celtic nearly as long as Ferguson was at Rangers and he wasn't the captain of Celtic either.

A better comparison would have been Lennon in his days at Celtic.

[the goal machine 7,806]

Was thinking the same

[disgruntled_bear 157]

It isn't really the same. McGeady hasn't been at Celtic nearly as long as Ferguson was at Rangers and he wasn't the captain of Celtic either.

A better comparison would have been Lennon in his days at Celtic.

McGeady has been at Celtic probably over 10years, I'd say thats long enough.

[disgruntled_bear 157]

Was thinking the same

Thank god somebody else see it

[BlueSuedeSambas 54,051]

I don't see it for the simple reason that McGeady isn't Celtic's captain, or the ring lieader of a clique.

[the goal machine 7,806]

Was thinking the same

Thank god somebody else see it

I just saw the comparisons between Strachan v McGeady and Ferguson v Le Guen.

I still back Ferguson though

[MayboleLoyal_atb 3,752]

Not realy the same. Strapon has won three titles in a row and got them to the last 16 of the CPL twice. PLG has down hee haw for us apart from blow the league by xmas and then get us knocked out of the CIS cup at home by lower league opposition.

[disgruntled_bear 157]

I don't see it for the simple reason that McGeady isn't Celtic's captain, or the ring leader of a clique.

McGeady is Celtic favourite son who is dyed in all there traditions, and brought through their youth set-up!

I'd say the comparison with Ferguson is not far off!

[BlueSuedeSambas 54,051]

It is.

Your clutching at straws here mate.

[disgruntled_bear 157]

Was thinking the same

Thank god somebody else see it

I just saw the comparisons between Strachan v McGeady and Ferguson v Le Guen.

I still back Ferguson though

Thats the point, the board will need to back one side.

I just wondering if they'll back the Manager or the Player

[MayboleLoyal_atb 3,752]

I don't see it for the simple reason that McGeady isn't Celtic's captain, or the ring leader of a clique.

McGeady is Celtic favourite son who is dyed in all there traditions, and brought through their youth set-up!

I'd say the comparison with Ferguson is not far off!

The comparison with the two managers however is way off the mark.

[disgruntled_bear 157]

It is.

Your clutching at straws here mate.

No i think too many, just don't want to admit the similarities between the two situations.

[papaguy51 912]

I wish we'd had more patience with PLG when I look back now.

[Simon. 7]

def def def not the same thing here. plg was having a nightmare in charge of us while wee chesney has won the 3 in a row so chesney is always gonna win that battle!

[MayboleLoyal_atb 3,752]

def def def not the same thing here. plg was having a nightmare in charge of us while wee chesney has won the 3 in a row so chesney is always gonna win that battle!

Glad someone else noticed.

[disgruntled_bear 157]

I don't see it for the simple reason that McGeady isn't Celtic's captain, or the ring leader of a clique.

McGeady is Celtic favourite son who is dyed in all there traditions, and brought through their youth set-up!

I'd say the comparison with Ferguson is not far off!

The comparison with the two managers however is way off the mark.

Manager Records are completely different, but atleast your willing to see some kind off comparison between the two

[McBoyd 355]

I wish we'd had more patience with PLG when I look back now.

Now i can question your football knowledge with that statement mate.

[disgruntled_bear 157]

def def def not the same thing here. plg was having a nightmare in charge of us while wee chesney has won the 3 in a row so chesney is always gonna win that battle!

I never said it was exactly the same.

But it is Player vs Manager....Who will the Celtic board back time will tell.

[papaguy51 912]

I wish we'd had more patience with PLG when I look back now.

Now i can question your football knowledge with that statement mate.

Aye, we've been so successful since he left

[AMMS 27]

I think you'll have to wait and see if the Celtc support boo Strachan from the bus on Saturday, chant McGeadys name all through the match and then boo Strachan after it and if Scott McDonald makes a gesture of support for McGeady in a nice public way. If that happens then we can start making comparisons. But if Celtc don't win their next 2 games it just might you know.

[McBoyd 355]

I wish we'd had more patience with PLG when I look back now.

Now i can question your football knowledge with that statement mate.

Aye, we've been so successful since he left

The PLG era was fucking shocking Papa, how on earth you'd want to go back to that i have no idea.

We were lying 5th at one point, we went out of the cup via a 1st Division team, he brought in some shite.

Aye, Walter hasn't brought in amazing players, but i'd say we are alot better off now than we were under PLG.

If you disagree you really are over exagerating.

[papaguy51 912]

I wish we'd had more patience with PLG when I look back now.

Now i can question your football knowledge with that statement mate.

Aye, we've been so successful since he left

The PLG era was fucking shocking Papa, how on earth you'd want to go back to that i have no idea.

I know, he really should have done so much better with that £3m he was given to spend.