five stars

He played too many minutes earlier in the season and lost form.
He's shown potential, but we need to be patient with young players and remember they are still developing. 
 

He's shown enough to be backed over the summer.
Hopefully he'll be different from our recent managers and actually learn from his mistakes. 

Ano what you’re saying mate just scunnered with these players. Give them everything and get fuckall back  

He made a mistake when he didn't drop Tav in his Ibrox Old Firm horror show.
You cannot pick a player who has performed so badly for the following game and expect to maintain harmony in the dressing room.
He also shouldn't of stuck up for the players after Ross County and Dundee.
He was stuck between a rock and a hard place.
Very difficult decisions to make, but the decisions he made showed weakness not strength. 

His interview when all games are done will be the most telling and will seal his fate with the fans. We need him to be honest. 

Started off as a breath of fresh air with intelligent positive play and clean, confident strikes from outside the box. And within a couple of months playing / training with our squad has regressed massively, looks like a different player and is now firmly in the 'only pass the ball to the closest centre half / Tavernier' camp. It's a common theme with many of our signings. Can only hope that his performance levels increase next season with better footballers around him rather than the current mess that can hardly pick out a blue jersey with a basic pass.

If it's true make him captain.

His time has been up for a long fucking time. Just glad everyone sees it now. Not only can he not defend, he never gets in the ref face the way mcgregor does for them. Should not even start next week.

If we have enough players back he should be on the bench with Sterling at RB.
That's if we want to win it?

Yip, take the fight to them and put their pacy players on the back foot for a change.

Or we could play Sterling and Sima on our right side (if fit) and we'd have them more worried about us on that side than we are about them?

He's been on the decline since the Europa final season. 
I'm amazed it's taken so long for many of here to realise it.
A blind man could see it after that the Old Firm game at Ibrox. 

If we have enough players back he should be on the bench with Sterling at RB.
That's if we want to win it?

Tav, Goldson and Lundstram are Emblematic of this team over past few years.
They simply all must go.

If it's true make him captain.

The most crucial thing for me with Tav at this point, as the with the rest of the players who have been here more than two seasons, is that they are ingrained in a culture of second place.
I've defended Tav plenty as he has bailed us out plenty, even this season at times and not just with penalties. However there is a clear decline in this play. Still a superb striker of the ball but his passing, his awareness and his defending is on level with some of his worst.
My real problem is the lack of winning culture that pre 2012 we would have culled already. It's not just Tav but this group of around 7/8/9 players does need gone for that culture more than anything. 
Tav as much as he has been one of our best footballers is sitting on 3 major domestic trophies in 25 attempts and the majority as captain. Him, Goldson, Lundstram, Barisic, Jack are the ones that new players look at and follow when they join Rangers and there is just no "know how" unlike across the city and that's what ultimately and won and lost this title.
Clement talks about end of the cycle now. I think we were at the end of the cycle after Seville.
 

How many of those were penalties?

How many of those were penalties?

Of course it's not all down to one player.
And there are other threads discussing the likes of Goldson and Lungstrum. 
But this thread is about Tav. His performances in the firsr half of the last Old Firm game at Ibrox was pathetic..
I'd would of subbed him before half-time. 
And he's been poor throughout the whole of the run in.
He's not good enough anymore.
 

Him and lundstram caused the 2nd at the piggery last sat
No one will deny his strikes etc, but they are becoming less and less but his defensive fuck ups arent
We're talking about potentially keeping someone for what they used to do, instead of what they currently do

Very positive Press Conference there. Needs now to get the full backing of everyone involved to raise the standards to where he wants them. It will be a tough job as he says because of the short turn around time but iam confident he can do it as long as he gets what he needs👍👍

Losing the cup final would be a terrible end to the season. Phil should tell anyone not willing to give 100 percent to inform him and he can find a willing replacement. That's literally the stage we are at imo.
I know a lot of players are moving on, but surely they want silverware, to reward our support and most importantly (allegedly) receive a win bonus?

It’s difficult to believe that he was the best candidate, whichever way you look at it.

Regardless of accusations of bias, this is a guy who been accused by all of continually trying to make the game about him.
Ridiculous appointment.

Sima's numbers were good for a winger before injury.