Should Diamond have been sent off

[Jamie1807 146]

I rewatched the match again last night

Diamond should have walked for that push

In the scuffle after it, Young pushed Jelavic in the face, if the ref had seen that he should of been sent off

Young again for stamping on McCulloch's spine

Maguire should of had a straight red for trying to end Kirk Broadfoot's career

[GeneralCartmanLee 313]

Anyone watch the athletico madrid game last night, hands raised...guy shoved ...red card.

A ref that follows the rules...

[jamd1986 8]

He raised his hands, and although it was only a push, the rules state that if you raise your hands it's a red card. Lafferty was sent off for the same offence at Easter Road.

Young was lucky to stay on the park as well. His tackle on Broadfoot was a potential ankle breaker.

[McBoyd 355]

In my eyes, for a penalty it's a "red, and a penalty" or neither.

He should have been off twice.

[SirWalterSmithLegend 206]

He raised his hands, and although it was only a push, the rules state that if you raise your hands it's a red card. Lafferty was sent off for the same offence at Easter Road.

Young was lucky to stay on the park as well. His tackle on Broadfoot was a potential ankle breaker.

Was that not Maguire? I thought that was his first yellow. Young should have been sent off for his deliberate stamp on Lee McCulloch, if Lee had been a Celtic player and made more of it like they do, Young would have been off.

[jamd1986 8]

Was that not Maguire? I thought that was his first yellow. Young should have been sent off for his deliberate stamp on Lee McCulloch, if Lee had been a Celtic player and made more of it like they do, Young would have been off.

Can't quite remember, so I'm probably wrong. But they were all at it yesterday. Lucky to finish the game with 10 men.

[SirWalterSmithLegend 206]

Can't quite remember, so I'm probably wrong. But they were all at it yesterday. Lucky to finish the game with 10 men.

A better and fairer referee would have had Aberdeen down to 8 men, we only had a 1 booking im sure, Naismith and he did NOT deserve his yellow.

[StayWestFree 107]

He should be sent off every game he plays just after the whistle goes at kick off for having the name "Zander". Sounds like he should be in some shitey American dram like One Tree Hill or Alias or something.

[Jamie1807 146]

Aberdeen should of been down to 8 long before they were down to 10

[Bluepeter9 5,167]

I am glad he stayed on - so they had no excuse for getting beat

2-0 and they fked it up!

Much better for Dimond to have been on the park for that!

[ZeGowse 13]

I voted yes but I think if he was sent off then Naismith probably would have been sent off too, both very similar incidents

[ryankyleakin 31]

He raised his hands, and although it was only a push, the rules state that if you raise your hands it's a red card. Lafferty was sent off for the same offence at Easter Road.

Young was lucky to stay on the park as well. His tackle on Broadfoot was a potential ankle breaker.

by that reckoning you must agree naismith should of been sent off aswell then?

[FieldMarshall85 16]

I would have sent him off just for being Zander Diamond

[SirWalterSmithLegend 206]

by that reckoning you must agree naismith should of been sent off aswell then?

Please tell us all, What did Naismith do? He done nothing wrong, defending your team mates is not a red card offense.

[Jamie1807 146]

by that reckoning you must agree naismith should of been sent off aswell then?

Naismith never raised his hands, Diamond did

Young also did this to Jelavic's face!

[grfc1975 1]

he should have been sent off by the ugly police. he has a face only a mother could love.

[TheNuts 552]

diamond is a T*rrier prick.

he knew exactly what he was doing.

[BLUEDIGNITY 33,647]

Only the presence of wille collum prevented him being sent off another cheat, we can expect more of this as the season goes on !

[blueben_d 40]

Raising your hands to an opponent is a red card offense by the letter of the law, particularly so with the force applied by Diamond. It wasn't just a wee handbag shove away it was a full out shove to the ground. Definate red, it doesn't have to be in the face, a shove of that ferocity is violent conduct without question.

[thebooler 4,509]

Normally I would say No - it wiz only a wee bit of a temper.

However, since it wiz for a foul on Vlado, I say the Ref shoulda sent him off - it would send out a warning to others that talent such as Vlado has will be allowed to flourish in this pish league.

[PudgieTheSheep 0]

I think that if Zander had gone then Naismith would have too for running 20-30 yards to get into the mix. Thought Young should have went for his part in it more so than Diamond.

[ForeverBlue_Since91 2,895]

I think that if Zander had gone then Naismith would have too for running 20-30 yards to get into the mix. Thought Young should have went for his part in it more so than Diamond.

diamond Was doing this all game though. plus diamond should have had a yellow,well before then. and if the ref would have did what he was supposed to do,he would have went.

You said in another thread,that it was alot of shite about not wanting just to beat us.?

what about this from diamond how do Aberdeen fans fell about him saying this.???. it's pretty shocking that a professional football player will come out and say someting like this. if this was a Rangers player saying this about Celtic,he would be slagged in the press. "You could lose every game of the season but if you beat Rangers you are afforded God-like status because of the history and significance attached to these matches.

[messiah10 58]

the bbc are biased bastards, dont show stokes tackle or his dive or young stamping on mculloch but they show mcgergor diving and mcgregor kicking out at maguire

[Jamie1807 146]

Zander Diamond is brutal

And to think people want him in the Scotland squad