Will Winning The Scottish Cup Change Your Mind

[tannerall 25,935]

Ally will still be manager regardless.

Winning the Scottish cup is unlikely, as on paper there are probably 4 better teams than us still in it, so would be a major achievement if Ally made it happen.

[Zander1 180]

For all the people who voted he should go even if we win the cup; do you realise how much of a laughing stock it would make us to sack a cup and league winning manager?

[TravelingWilBEARy 4,319]

not really - winning the Scottish cup without having to play Pacific Shelf is not exactly fantastic for us. for a team without a 6 million pound budget maybe. but i get you back McCoist because you are taking a long term view. I'm taking a long term view as well - i just dont think McCoist is it.

Really? Where have you been the last 2 years?

[insider 123]

Ally deserves a shot next year. We'r winning ugly but that's better than losing.

[allgers 735]

Can I ask thoae who want to give him another chance next season, at what point would you change your mind?

Two or three defeats?

Not sitting top by October?

Not sitting top by Christmas?

Those of us who have had enough genuinely want to know how poor the performances need to be, how bad we have to get for you guys to say "ENOUGH"?

Even you diehards must have a breaking point - what is it?

Can I turn that around on you, at what point will you decide you are wrong, when we win every game in October, when we lose a few players in the summer and bring in a few choice players who normally wouldn't want to play in the 2nd tier of any football league but want to be part of something special, like we mostly did last year before it turned sour for some.

[don logan 8,062]

Unless there are a couple of seismic shocks in the quarters, we've no chance of winning the cup.

[Big Al 55 9,249]

No I'd still prefer DK over hedge funds

[siddiqi_drinker 14,635]

Unless there are a couple of seismic shocks in the quarters, we've no chance of winning the cup.

Love the No Surrender attitude

[Lisburn Rangers 254]

He got his go at the championship and ballsed a healthy lead up

He also ballsed up in the 1st rounds of both European cups v poor opposition . he brought in poor signings in bedoya Ortiz and mckay . say no more

[The Educator 1,572]

Not a fair questionnaire in that there is no response allowed for those who feel he should stay whether or not we win any cups.

[TeddybearTam 9]

I have man love for McCoist the man, as for the manager... no thanks.

[The Educator 1,572]

Crespie6 - "winning the Scottish cup without having to play Pacific Shelf is not exactly fantastic for us"

That sounds like something that would actually come from one of the Pacific Self support or the mhedia rather than from a Rangers fan.

[Redwhiteandblue 3,330]

I never wanted him to get the job in the first place, and my predictiond at the time have unfortunately come true.

Although, Ally was 100% the cortect man to see us through the problems we encountered after the season ended in the admin season.

[Crespie6 334]

Crespie6 - "winning the Scottish cup without having to play Pacific Shelf is not exactly fantastic for us"

That sounds like something that would actually come from one of the Pacific Self support or the mhedia rather than from a Rangers fan.

in what way? you seriously think that with the resources we have we should not be winning at least one cup a year? (the Ramsdens should be a shoe-in.). i'll ignore your accusation

[Cooperfan 35]

He quite clearly has NOT 'earned' the sack, Scottish Cup win or not.

[Queens 11 127]

As much as I hate watching out current brand of football, I'd like to see if we improve against tougher opposition with Ally still in charge. If however we have a shocker at the start of next season, I would have to be thinking his time is up.

[Madina 3,812]

I really see us fucking up this golden chance of winning the cup, if so then I'd probably have to say (sadly) that Ally should depart

[1st_Jan_1994 4,868]

My choice isn't on the list

Winning this Scottish cup won't turn you into a great manager overnight, but it would be a great achievement

I still want a better quality manager but winning the Scottish cup would give him a chance to push on and improve as a manager in folks eyes it depends on how he'd take the opportunity tho

[BooBoo2012 4]

Realistically, in order to win the SC, we will need to beat 2 SPL teams, in the semis and final. If we do that, then this will demonstrate that we are getting there.

If we lose in the quarters or get hammered at Ibrox in the semi against the pish that are left, then Ally needs to go.

[Right_To_Censor 1,951]

As much as I hate watching out current brand of football, I'd like to see if we improve against tougher opposition with Ally still in charge. If however we have a shocker at the start of next season, I would have to be thinking his time is up.

when we where in the spl under ally, our style of play was murder, fast forward a year later and it was bad, real mind numbing bad, same mistakes being made week in week out, no amount of talking fixed the problem, fast forward another year later and nothing has changed, my faith in him is an all time low no amount of cups, finals, league wins is gonna change that fact.

[Bad Robot 21,150]

Ally will still be manager regardless.

Winning the Scottish cup is unlikely, as on paper there are probably 4 better teams than us still in it, so would be a major achievement if Ally made it happen.

We only need to beat 2 of the 4

[TravelingWilBEARy 4,319]

when we where in the spl under ally, our style of play was murder, fast forward a year later and it was bad, real mind numbing bad, same mistakes being made week in week out, no amount of talking fixed the problem, fast forward another year later and nothing has changed, my faith in him is an all time low no amount of cups, finals, league wins is gonna change that fact.

[TravelingWilBEARy 4,319]

To be fair, anyone who says 'no' to this can't have much of a mind to change.

[1st_Jan_1994 4,868]

To be fair, anyone who says 'no' to this can't have much of a mind to change.

Winning one cup doesn't make you a good manager overnight

Winning it would be fantastic but he'd still have a long way to go but it would be a damned good start and buy him more time and rightly so IMO

[TravelingWilBEARy 4,319]

Winning one cup doesn't make you a good manager overnight

Winning it would be fantastic but he'd still have a long way to go but it would be a damned good start and buy him more time and rightly so IMO

No-one has claimed it would. What it would/should do is start to change peoples minds - especially those who are adamant that he's 'never a manager'.