McGregor or Alexander?

[Jackie1690 0]

The question speaks for itself

I think Alexander should get given another chance - he took us to the UEFA Cup Final and he was outstanding

[NOLUWDC 1]

I said Alexander before the season started but McGregor has got his old form back and deserves to stay in.

[TexasGers 96]

McGregor, he's been one of the few bright spots recently and deserves to keep his place

[Muff 245]

You can't drop Allan McGregor at this moment in time!

One of our most consistant and best performers.

[Tumshie 205]

Don't think Alexander deserved to be dropped but on this form neither does Alan McGregor

[Poetry_In_Blue 1,043]

McGregor has prevented us from being beaten by a lot more goals this season so there is no way we should drop him.

[bluepeter 5,627]

I've ranted for a long time that Alexander is the better keeper, should never have lost his place, etc, etc.

However, McGregor is in place and playing very well. He even seems to have been working on his distribution, which is a big problem in his game. There is no way he should be dropped at the moment.

Now, if he can work on the cross balls as well.......

[WaltersGotStyle 172]

The question speaks for itself

I think Alexander should get given another chance - he took us to the UEFA Cup Final and he was outstanding

How can you say that?

[Dextor 0]

I can't believe we're have another McGregor or Alexander poll.

Surely this argument has been settled. McGregor has been fantastic this season and anyone who knows anything about football will tell you he's a better keeper than Alexander.

[bluenoz 32,161]

The best selection decision Smith has made all season.

[maxwellrfc 6]

McGregor

[GersxChick 15]

[Otis 1]

At the start of season i felt that Alexander was hard done by and i still satnd by that but McGregor is slightly the better of the 2 and should continue to be number 1 choice. Harsh on Alexander i know but thats football.

We should be happy that we have 2 top keepers in our squad.

[WilliamFyfe 1,438]

Based on this guys..

If we had to sell, then I'd sell McGregor.

I wasn't in favor of him just walking back into the team buts he done brilliant and been one of our top performers recently but if it did come down to selling players like I said I'd sell McGregor and hold onto Alexander

:pierre:

[GovanFrontGers 1]

Defo McGregor

[Gaz52 11,837]

Big Aldo MaC ya Dobber!

[papaguy51 941]

McGregor's knuckled down and improved his overall game.

He's probably Britain's in-form keeper at the moment. Some of the saves he's producing are just unreal.

[Chookes 21]

McGregor has been fantastic for most of this season. I felt Alexander should have kept his place at the start of this season but McGregor has definitely repaid Smith for showing faith in him.

[caseyjones 3,009]

Alexander. His all-round game is superior. McGregor is a very good shot-stopper.

[BRITNEY IS NOT FEELING IT 8,293]

McGregor is number 1 ,at the moment.

Although between McGregor and Alexander,there isnt much of a difference,

(Alexander imo didn't deserve to be dropped,although McGregor is doing the business)Great position the club is in ,to have both of them.

WATP

[smitzer007 198]

At the start of season i felt that Alexander was hard done by and i still satnd by that but McGregor is slightly the better of the 2 and should continue to be number 1 choice. Harsh on Alexander i know but thats football.

We should be happy that we have 2 top keepers in our squad.

Only slightly disagree in that I think McGregor, on form, is a much better keeper but we are lucky to have Alexander as back up.

[Jimfanciesthedude 25,475]

if shagger was only better at cross balls we would have a keeper worth 10million in my opinion

[Scott-RFC 308]

McGregor is repaying the faith Smith showed in him big time at the minute

[dbyst 570]

no doubt alexander has done a superb job when needed but mcgregor is the better keeper IMO

[MasterD 7,448]

McGregor