Would you like Hill for another season?

[Jack The Flipper 5,936]

As long as he adds value to the squad...

Ahem... sorry 

[esquire8 42,751]

Afraid not, been a bright star in a shoddy season so far but age is obviously not on his side. Would thank him for all he has done and would possibly offer a rolling contract/keep training with us until he could get a new club so he isn't left on the scrap heap. 

[TMB 14,167]

1 hour ago, ForeverAndEver said:

Bougherra better than Weir?.

You don't half post a lot of shite btw.

Bougherra was a wonderful CB for us.  Even when we were in the Champions League he, at times, looked a class apart.  Against the Tims he excelled and I think there's a stat about us never losing a game against them when Bougherra played?  Not sure.

It's all about opinions but I think Bougherra was better than Weir.  You're welcome to disagree it's all about opinions ? 

[foghorn leghorn 608]

6 minutes ago, esquire8 said:

Afraid not, been a bright star in a shoddy season so far but age is obviously not on his side. Would thank him for all he has done and would possibly offer a rolling contract/keep training with us until he could get a new club so he isn't left on the scrap heap. 

That's how I feel about Wilson and Kiernan. If only Davy Weir could be on the park to mentor Wilson again as he did 6 years ago.

[bluenose48 951]

Yes one more year as a bench player.

We need two proper centre backs.

[We Will Follow Rangers 12,921]

Clint hill looks relatively good in a shockingly bad back line, I admire the guys effort and applaud his professionalism to keep going but he's indicative of where we're at not part of where we're going,

We need 2 new quick dominant centre backs, a combative def mid and a striker, be really interested in seeing the affect of Pedro's training on the likes of Kranjcar, he could be a big player for us next season, if Pedro can make us secure at the back it will improve the entire team.

[ForeverAndEver 71,494]

48 minutes ago, THE_MIGHTY_BEARS said:

Bougherra was a wonderful CB for us.  Even when we were in the Champions League he, at times, looked a class apart.  Against the Tims he excelled and I think there's a stat about us never losing a game against them when Bougherra played?  Not sure.

It's all about opinions but I think Bougherra was better than Weir.  You're welcome to disagree it's all about opinions ? 

Lost at least 3.

Weir was twice the defender Bougherra ever was.

[We Will Follow Rangers 12,921]

Weirs positional sense and organisation made every defender he played with look good, ffs even Danny Wilson, all the more astonishing couldn't pass that on to players as a coach

[Blue Avenger 22,567]

1 minute ago, wewillfollowrangers said:

Weirs positional sense and organisation made every defender he played with look good, ffs even Danny Wilson, all the more astonishing couldn't pass that on to players as a coach

The player he is passing it onto has to have some ability. Wilson has no pace, not imposing and poor awareness.

[LaudrupsPatrickBoots 13,510]

I think he deserves another year but as much as I like him I don't think he's good enough to be our main defender and I doubt he has another full season of playing every week in him anyway.

If he stays it's as a squad player imo.

[We Will Follow Rangers 12,921]

7 minutes ago, Blue Avenger said:

The player he is passing it onto has to have some ability. Wilson has no pace, not imposing and poor awareness.

Weir never had any pace either, of course you cant polish a turd but to me it is odd that a guy who's biggest strength as  player was his tactical sense and organisation skills could'nt coach an even half decent defence

[MasterD 7,435]

No.

We need better to start and he's probably on a decent wage that could be better used elsewhere rather than a 3rd/4th choice.

We need to free up wages and players out of contract will likely be the first to go. Others we'll struggle to move on.

[bettertogether 381]

Voted yes only as a squad player next season but he is absolutely the first name on my team sheet for the semi final.

[cumnockbear 2,446]

I'll be sad to see him go, but i would offer him another year as back up. 

[VladimirWeiss69 802]

There is obviously a lot in the yes camp, thought it would have been in the other direction judging by the comments ??

[KingKirk 25,647]

Will be sad to see him go but its for the best.....  

[Bertent 2,081]

Given there are at least two at the back Id like to see out of the door first yes. I mean how likely are we to sign 3 centre halfs over the summer if we were to say thanks but no thanks? 

 

[reallyruff 622]

Despite seeing his value to the current team I voted no on the basis that his remaining may indicate a failure to address the issues we currently suffer in that area of the team. This hopefully isn't a case of throwing the baby out with the bathwater but rather an opportunity for PC to get his own men in and build a team capable of sustaining a challenge and adopting a long term approach and not simply apply a bandaid to this crucial area of the team, something his predecessor failed to address adequately. 

[JC10 1,449]

Don't see why not - preferably as a squad player not starter.

[simplythebest 11,453]

11 hours ago, bettertogether said:

Voted yes only as a squad player next season but he is absolutely the first name on my team sheet for the semi final.

And you have that as your username!?