Kenny Miller - Hall Of Fame?

[loyalfollower 1,543]

I'm no fan of this hall of fame shite but do you just stop it after the 9 in a row side??  All these things are is an excuse for a big piss up. In 15 years time it's quite possible that rob kiernan could be inducted into it.. 

the club can only induct the players it has had at any previous time.  Say what you like about Miller but he has gave us some brilliant memories and has been a good servant for Rangers football club. 

[RDFM 3,809]

I love Kenny but if it were up to me I'd have no one that has had an affiliation with Celtic in the HoF.

 

Its also been diluted a bit with certain additions, which begs the question of if it should be kept exclusively for legends or just club icons and greats.

[Deanzmeanzheinz 4,312]

That's funny me and my mates were discussing all this after last weeks game. 

Firstly kenny - yes, I think he deserves it. We sold him first time out. He didn't ask to leave the club, he was traded. Ok, he joined them and that thumper celebration still sticks in my craw. But of course Alfie Conn is in it so to deny him for that reason is wrong. 

Secondly, the additions since Barry Ferguson was last on it are all virtually embarrassing. One guy I would love to see on it from the last 10-15 years is Ronald de Boer - now that was a player! 

Finally, for me anyway, Lee Wallace is a must. He was and is the torch bearer for our great club through all these last 4-5 years. He has had sticky times in those years but giving the clusterfuck that went on in and around our club you can understand that. He possesses that great virtue that many real Rangers legends in the past portrayed - LOYALTY - while every rhat deserted the ship Lee was first into training that first day back in season 2012/13 and vowed never to leave and he could have several times. He sacrificed his international career for us - there is no doubt about that. In short, he put our great club before himself. That alone makes him Hall of Fame material. 

[Bluebear11 134]

I would take Ally out of it. Still has those penny shares and was a horrible manager for us

[Prso's headband 35,570]

No. 

Once Lee Wallace wins the trophies he hasn't as a Rangers player he should be first in the queue. The first 3 were essentially a given but it will be unique in the sense no other Rangers player has done or will ever do it again. 

 

[STEPPS BOY 74,149]

A stand should be named after him imo..

[Loyal Bear 72 363]

6 hours ago, K.A.I said:

Nothing against Weir, Miller, Ricksen, Jig but no not for the hall of fame

If Novo never scored that penalty in Florence id include him in that too 

good players as they were having them in devalues the hall of fame it should be for the likes of the Barca Bears, Goram, Gough, McCoist (hate myself saying the cunts name), Walter Smith (if managers allowed)

No Weir in the Hall of Fame? Are you having a laugh?

[.Williamson. 82,546]

5 minutes ago, Loyal Bear 72 said:

No Weir in the Hall of Fame? Are you having a laugh?

Why should Weir be in it?

Do people get in it for being Rangers men? Weir came in late on in his career and make no mistake his services were first class, but hall of fame material? Naw.

[Alec87 331]

Wasn't Ricksen booed during his last game at Ibrox in a friendly playing for Zenit ?

[Loyal Bear 72 363]

6 minutes ago, .Williamson. said:

Why should Weir be in it?

Do people get in it for being Rangers men? Weir came in late on in his career and make no mistake his services were first class, but hall of fame material? Naw.

Came at the age of the 36 on a 6 month deal and ended up captaining us to 8 trophies and a european final over 3 seasons. His age only made it more remarkable. Of course he should be in it.

[K.A.I 36,183]

12 minutes ago, Loyal Bear 72 said:

No Weir in the Hall of Fame? Are you having a laugh?

 why? nothing against the guy but seriously why? good player, done us a good turn for a couple seasons especially at his age ... but so what?

You include Weir then you include scores more similar.

Weir was a good center-half for us btw but this is why the hall of fame is devalued.

[.Williamson. 82,546]

Just now, Loyal Bear 72 said:

Came at the age of the 36 on a 6 month deal and ended up captaining us to 8 trophies and a european final over 3 seasons. His age only makes it more remarkable. Of course he should be in it.

Barry was our captain in the uefa cup final mate

[Loyal Bear 72 363]

Just now, K.A.I said:

 why? nothing against the guy but seriously why? good player, done us a good turn for a couple seasons especially at his age ... but so what?

You include Weir then you include scores more similar.

Weir was a good center-half for us btw but this is why the hall of fame is devalued.

It may be devalued by the amount of players in it but not by Weir. People still underestimate him for us. It's no surprise Wilson, Bougherra, Perry and even Cuellar all seemed to be at their best next to him. As I said captaining us at his age to 8 trophies and a european final is more than enough to justify his inclusion. 

[K.A.I 36,183]

4 minutes ago, Loyal Bear 72 said:

Came at the age of the 36 on a 6 month deal and ended up captaining us to 8 trophies and a european final over 3 seasons. His age only made it more remarkable. Of course he should be in it.

OK then Broadfoot, Kevin Thomson, Papac, Boyd, Davis next in

[Loyal Bear 72 363]

5 minutes ago, .Williamson. said:

Barry was our captain in the uefa cup final mate

That's true. Should have remembered Weir was captain after Ferguson was stripped of it.

[Alec87 331]

..

[Alec87 331]

53 minutes ago, Bluebear11 said:

I would take Ally out of it. Still has those penny shares and was a horrible manager for us

Just out of interest. Do you think Miller should be in ?

[heathen fish boy 8,584]

Yes for me,ok he had a wee misdemeanour during his career but he's shown where his heart truly lies,would run through brick walls for us and instills the no surrender attitude I wish all our players possessed 

[Leeds_Bear 8,110]

7 hours ago, K.A.I said:

Nothing against Weir, Miller, Ricksen, Jig but no not for the hall of fame

If Novo never scored that penalty in Florence id include him in that too 

good players as they were having them in devalues the hall of fame it should be for the likes of the Barca Bears, Goram, Gough, McCoist (hate myself saying the cunts name), Walter Smith (if managers allowed)

Novo's scored some vitally important goals over his career at Rangers. Winners in cup finals, league title campaigns, champions league qualifiers, European knockout rounds and six goals against that mob.

I'd say that's hall of fame material. 

Comparing him with those guys isn't all that fair I'd say as they all played in different periods with different external factors. 

(He also said no ???)

 

[K.A.I 36,183]

Just now, Leeds_Bear said:

Novo's scored some vitally important goals over his career at Rangers. Winners in cup finals, league title campaigns, champions league qualifiers, European knockout rounds and six goals against that mob.

I'd say that's hall of fame material. 

Comparing him with those guys isn't all that fair I'd say as they all played in different periods with different external factors. 

(He also said no ???)

 

So has plenty of others that's not in the HOF - that's the point. 

It's not that they weren't good for us - they were but others (myself included) think a hall of fame should be for over and above players. Novo, Miller, Weir, Ricksen etc don't fit into that category for me. 

[Leeds_Bear 8,110]

Just now, K.A.I said:

So has plenty of others that's not in the HOF - that's the point. 

It's not that they weren't good for us - they were but others (myself included) think a hall of fame should be for over and above players. Novo, Miller, Weir, Ricksen etc don't fit into that category for me. 

Fair enough I don't disagree. My arguement is Novo did go over and above. 

[CF2 WINNIE 1,006]

I'd say yes. As the point has already been made, nothing against them but, Ricksen,Novo McCulloch are yes fans favourites but not Rangers legends. If they are in than Kenny Miller should be to

[Courtyard Bear 41,357]

He deserves to be on it long before McCulloch Ricksen and Novo that's for sure. 

I think it's time the voting process was taken out of the fans hands and left to a committee of past players. 

[jackrfc95 4,255]

16 minutes ago, Leeds_Bear said:

Fair enough I don't disagree. My arguement is Novo did go over and above. 

Love Novo don't get me wrong but he was only a certain starter in one season he was here.

[Bruno's Manbun 2,631]

Kenny has been a good servant of the club but I don't think he'll go into the hall of fame