Players you didn't/don't rate but everybody else seemed to?

[ForeverAndEver 71,501]

Candeias for me

[mitre_mouldmaster 21,509]

Hemdani

[simplythebest 11,453]

McCulloch probably, even in his earlier times with us I just never really saw it 

[gsa 3,906]

Klos for me. 

Although that was maybe a case of just not rating him as highly as others rather than not rating him at all.

[KeyserSoze 14,545]

3 minutes ago, ForeverAndEver said:

Candeias for me

He’s still here though  

 

Gary Steven for me

 

 

[ForeverAndEver 71,501]

1 minute ago, KeyserSoze said:

He’s still here though  

 

Gary Steven for me

 

 

And?

[35 Yard Dangerman 3,476]

Mikel Arteta and Thomas Buffel.

[BlueThunder 8,454]

I’m going to start a thread called ‘players you thought were rubbish, and were rubbish’. Everyone else seems to be getting in on the act 

 

[Dan Deacon 55,223]

Gazza

[Brian Fantana 28,894]

Buffell

Danny Wilson in his first spell (Weir kept him right in games)

 

 

[CoopsLaud 4,186]

Of the ones already mentioned the only one I agree with is Buffel. Always wound me up to fuck when 2 season ticket holders I worked with would rip arteta to bits every second week. I thought he was class.

[King Jela 20,361]

14 minutes ago, simplythebest said:

McCulloch probably, even in his earlier times with us I just never really saw it 

Don’t remember any big clamour for McCulloch ?

[CoopsLaud 4,186]

4 minutes ago, Dan Deacon said:

Gazza

See I thought of gazza first but it was more that he irritated me a bit as a person. Even with us he still showed flashes of his world class.

[kris1984 1,259]

Alan Hutton (apart from last 6 months)

[StaunchLondonGer 1,651]

19 minutes ago, BlueThunder said:

I’m going to start a thread called ‘players you thought were rubbish, and were rubbish’. Everyone else seems to be getting in on the act 

 

I like it!  I'm gonna go for...

'Players who started well then went off the boil a bit but latterly came good again and were sold on for a decent wedge thus ultimately representing sound value for the club'

[StaunchLondonGer 1,651]

15 minutes ago, CoopsLaud said:

See I thought of gazza first but it was more that he irritated me a bit as a person. Even with us he still showed flashes of his world class.

And what flashes they were!

[Ryju84 3,170]

34 minutes ago, ForeverAndEver said:

Candeias for me

First name in my head. 

[CoopsLaud 4,186]

6 minutes ago, StaunchLondonGer said:

And what flashes they were!

Something else. One man demolition of the sheep comes immediately to mind.

[Dan Deacon 55,223]

28 minutes ago, CoopsLaud said:

See I thought of gazza first but it was more that he irritated me a bit as a person. Even with us he still showed flashes of his world class.

I was joking 

[CoopsLaud 4,186]

1 minute ago, Dan Deacon said:

I was joking 

Obv.

[Inigo 32,532]

24 minutes ago, kris1984 said:

Alan Hutton (apart from last 6 months)

It was more like 18 months. And before that he was young and developing, but during that time he got the usual ridiculous grief meeted out to young players after a year or so in the first team, so I don't think you were actually alone in that one.

[SeparateEntityMyArse 53,725]

Bates.

Ginger Maldini my arse. 

[K.A.I 36,183]

Loads ..

Some of these were OK just more over-rated rather than not rating them outright...

Papac, Hemdani, Bates, Jack, Rossiter, Andrews, Broadfoot, Taverneir, McPherson, Watterus, Edu, Petric, Bjorklund, Johansson, Vidmar, Konterman, Beasley, Spackman, A.Rae.

Some of them did jobs so I'm not saying I never rated them at all, just not that highly. Not all of them were highly rated by everyone either. 

[Spliffy 643]

Waterreus

[Inigo 32,532]

Essentially this thread could be renamed players you didny rate but in relation to whom you had no idea what you were talking about. We all have those players.

Klos, Stevens, Arteta and Hutton are doozies.