Which of the four players would we miss the most?

[GOAT 30,449]

For me that should answer who the player of the year should be.  You can 100% notice the difference in the middle of the park when Davis doesn’t play.  But for me, I reckon out of everyone we’d 110% miss Goldson out of the four. 
 

so the polls not who you think POTY should be I’m asking who do you think we’d miss most.

[The Godfather 71,893]

Each one we would miss big time but for me the keeper has made several incredible saves in huge games this season and a good keeper is hard to come by like AM. 

[GRFC96 75]

Hard because they’ve all been excellent but mcgregor due to the saves he makes that can win a game.

[bluenoz 30,839]

I voted for Goldson for player of the year but good goalies are harder to find. McGregor would be missed the most.

[Valance1690 3,826]

As good as McGregor & Tav have been, we've had replacements in for them this season & we've not struggled in the games where McLaughlin/Patterson have played, so much so that people where questioning whether they would get back into the team. Not saying McLaughlin would've made the worldies McGregor has but I think we'd have still found a way through games. 

Goldson has been a mainstay & has been solid, would be interesting to see how the defence is without him, whether a partnership like Helander/Simpson or Balogun/Katic would work we simply don't know. 

For me tho it's got to be Davis, he's been immense, a 36 year old who has played more games than any other midfielder at the club this season whilst still representing his country. Gives you at least a 7/10 every single week & in the games he hasn't played you've noticed the difference, we're going to be hard pressed to find someone to replace him without spending a fortune. 

[BuffaloUSAGers 1,235]

On the field I think we would miss Davis the most. 365 days ago I would never have imagined typing those words.

[Jimfanciesthedude 24,545]

Keeper by a mile, many times he has kept us in the game before the outfield 10 have woken up

[left winger 14,179]

Dunno. Depends on their replacements.

[Sket 13,610]

McGregor 100%

[.Williamson. 82,216]

McGregor will be hardest to replace but Goldson is player of the year

[gmcf 34,194]

Would have gone for McGregor , but I dont think Jon McLaughlin has let us down when called upon , so I've gone for Goldson whose been a rock this season . 

[STEPPS BOY 73,922]

Mcgregor.

[BlueKnight87 17,286]

McGregor. The saves he's made this season have been absolutely incredible. A great goalkeeper is worth 10-15 points a season. 

[peter huistra 1,740]

Gotta be Tav is goals/assets plus his drive and leadership in the early part of the season were crucial, had he not got injured he would be a clear winner for me but Mcgregor has been unbelievable too especially against them.

 

[tannerall 25,935]

Better question might be which player would be the most difficult to replace.

I'm thinking good quality experienced goalkeepers may be at a premium.

[Canabear 4,558]

There has been times when i've said all 4 for poty as at times all 4 have had fantastic spells.

This has to be one of the hardest years to select a winner but i voted for Goldson simply because he's been there game in game out and hasn't really made a mistake that i can think of especially when Tavernier was out injured.

Mr. Reliable for me but like i said there is a case for all 4 of them.

[Canabear 4,558]

8 minutes ago, tannerall said:

Better question might be which player would be the most difficult to replace.

I'm thinking good quality experienced goalkeepers may be at a premium.

I think we have a quality replacement in McLaughlin. He's got 8 clean sheets this season.

He's not as good as McGregor but who is.

[Corky True Legend 2,682]

Voted for Davis. When he has been absent we have not been so creative. We have still looked solid when Tav & Shagger have not been in the side and Goldson has had a few poor games.

[Ross-Gazza genius 1,907]

5 hours ago, GOAT said:

For me that should answer who the player of the year should be.  You can 100% notice the difference in the middle of the park when Davis doesn’t play.  But for me, I reckon out of everyone we’d 110% miss Goldson out of the four. 
 

so the polls not who you think POTY should be I’m asking who do you think we’d miss most.

Not really, Patterson could cover for Tav and we wouldn't miss him, mclaughlin could cover for mcgregor and we might not miss him as much, Balogun could cover for Goldson but we don't have adequate cover for Davis. It's not a true reflection on how to decide who is player of the year. For me there's a bawhair in it between McGregor, Goldson and Tavernier. 

[tannerall 25,935]

All 4 would be a huge loss, but on character and general mischievousness alone would be McGregor for sure. 

 

[KaiserJon 12,393]

3 minutes ago, tannerall said:

All 4 would be a huge loss, but on character and general mischievousness alone would be McGregor for sure. 

 

Seriously bugger off to pinpointing corners down the park. You were on here every minute up to us actually achieving 55 and then disappeared, odd behaviour. You bang on about being involved in other teams and what not in Eastbourne so go do that. I would not take your opinion on pretty much anything seriously.

You may be from Glasgow but doubt you are are a Rangers fan.

[tannerall 25,935]

5 minutes ago, badjon said:

Seriously bugger off to pinpointing corners down the park. You were on here every minute up to us actually achieving 55 and then disappeared, odd behaviour. You bang on about being involved in other teams and what not in Eastbourne so go do that. I would not take your opinion on pretty much anything seriously.

You may be from Glasgow but doubt you are are a Rangers fan.

Wrong on every count, except I'm Glaswegian and proud of it, Do you have anything factual to add to all those inaccuracies ?

Seriously, bugger off to minding your own business, not mine. 

Good night and good riddance, look forward to not hearing from you again, unless you can't stop yourself. 

[KaiserJon 12,393]

It's not a matter of stopping myself it's more a matter of simply you cannot refute this...

[tannerall 25,935]

3 minutes ago, badjon said:

It's not a matter of stopping myself it's more a matter of simply you cannot refute this...

Should change your username to sadjon mate.

[KaiserJon 12,393]

1 minute ago, tannerall said:

Should change your username to sadjon mate.

So resulting to that. You are a joke. I am sure @Bronzy can @ you with the sadjon if you wish.