Who do you consider to have been a successful signing?

[DiamondDan 2,386]

I have listed all the players signed under Ross Wilson's reign. Who do you think has been a success?

I voted Bassey, I don't think anyone else on that list has improved the team. Harsh on Lundstram but he's no better than the rest of the centre midfielders we already have.

Balagoun has done a turn when he's played, but nowhere near of the required standard, consistency or fitness of Goldson.

The rest range from ineffectual,  unreliable to utter wastes of a wage.

When you look at that list, then the case to dismiss Wilson is utterly compelling. Horrendous.

[G.E.C. 19,583]

McLaughlin, Bassey, Hagi, Balogun and Roofe.

Lundstram close to a vote.

[The Godfather 75,508]

Sands 😆 

[DiamondDan 2,386]

Just now, The Godfather said:

Sands 😆 

Someone voted Diallo 😂

[Negri's lovechild 15,338]

Have voted Bassey and Lundstram. Others could be argued for, but they have either been back up signings (McLaughlin), or fairly injury probe (Balogun).

[10pshortof17pound 2,623]

3 minutes ago, DiamondDan said:

Someone voted Diallo 😂

Probably a curve ball - wouldn’t trust him to run a grocery store!

[SPWF 8,908]

Hagi, Balogun and Roofe all contributed in a big way to the league title last season, so for that they get a vote. I’d still chase them all out the door the though 🤷🏼‍♂️

[McEwan's Lager 31,970]

I think nowadays we can't just judge on the park, also have to judge whether or not they increase their value and sale potential in order for us as a club to be successful. With that in mind...

McLaughlin has been a good signing. Proved more than an able back up.

I think we will make some money off Bassey, despite him not being that great. Would say then he has been a decent signing.

While Hagi has had some poor moments he's also been really brilliant at times and we should get a return. Balogun and Roofe are in the same category except we won't make any money out of them. All three and McLaughlin played a big part in bringing home 55 so that counts a lot for being good signings.

Simpson is horrific, easily one of the worst players I've seen for us in the top flight. Will end up playing in League 2. Every man and his dog knew he would be utter shite. We will end up paying him off.

Lundstram is really coming on to a game but for the money we are paying him I'd expect him to be the best player on the pitch every game. I'm not sure we will get that out of him and I can see him being here for the length of his contract and leave on a free.

Wright is poor. No sale value.

Bacuna was a poor signing but we got him for nothing and shifted him out the door quickly. Hopefully we aren't paying a contribution to his wage.

Sakala I can't see him ever being more than a bit part player and he'll end up back at the level of club he was playing at before us.

Who knows with Ofoborh. Looks a horrific waste of wages.

If Ramsey scores the winner in the Europa League final then the signing will be a success and we will be an instant hero. If we end up winning nothing this year it's an expensive shambles of a signing.

Sands looks ok. We still have another year to evaluate.

Zukowski is apparently terrible and not even good enough for the B team. 

[The Hammer 11 2,824]

13 minutes ago, The Godfather said:

Sands 😆 

Sands will come good , he was good in the MLS which is now a higher standard than the bulk of the SPFL , needs a run of games starting 

[The Godfather 75,508]

1 minute ago, The Hammer 11 said:

Sands will come good , he was good in the MLS which is now a higher standard than the bulk of the SPFL , needs a run of games starting 

I don't see it tbh.

Looks like a bog standard mid table SPFL midfielder. Nothing stands out with him for me.

Hopefully wrong but with the standard of player we have brought in the past 18 months I doubt I am.

[The Hammer 11 2,824]

Just now, The Godfather said:

I don't see it tbh.

Looks like a big standard mid table SPFL midfielder. Nothing stands out with him for me.

Hopefully wrong but with the standard of player we have brought in the past 18 months I doubt I am.

I’ll be honest mate I don’t think he suits our system but a new manager could get him up to be a top player. To be fair I watch the MLS a good bit and he was highly rated and came from a team that won their league and cup that year 

[SIRB_72 4,148]

Voted for McLaughlin, Hagi, Roofe, Bassey, Balogun & Lundstram. All but Bassey & Lundstram have contributed to a title winning team and I think Bassey in terms of value has been a pretty good signing.

Didnt vote for Sakala but I do think there is something there but looking at it honestly I can't see where he fits, especially in the strategy we signed him to play in.

I think Zukowski and Sands can't be deemed a failure but neither a success. Both will be on buttons as well.

[HG5 12,175]

7 minutes ago, The Hammer 11 said:

I’ll be honest mate I don’t think he suits our system but a new manager could get him up to be a top player. To be fair I watch the MLS a good bit and he was highly rated and came from a team that won their league and cup that year 

Given it’s success (1 trophy out of 16 competed for, and I know that could possibly rise by one or two) maybe it’s time to look at our system?

As half the team will be gone over the summer, no time like the present!

[MVRanger 2,864]

Lundstrum, Bassey. Kemar Roofe and Hagi...

Hang on - there might be a song there 

[Moody Blue 9,983]

What a list of dross we have 

[WWTC 2,450]

49 minutes ago, McEwan's Lager said:

I think nowadays we can't just judge on the park, also have to judge whether or not they increase their value and sale potential in order for us as a club to be successful. With that in mind...

McLaughlin has been a good signing. Proved more than an able back up.

I think we will make some money off Bassey, despite him not being that great. Would say then he has been a decent signing.

While Hagi has had some poor moments he's also been really brilliant at times and we should get a return. Balogun and Roofe are in the same category except we won't make any money out of them. All three and McLaughlin played a big part in bringing home 55 so that counts a lot for being good signings.

Simpson is horrific, easily one of the worst players I've seen for us in the top flight. Will end up playing in League 2. Every man and his dog knew he would be utter shite. We will end up paying him off.

Lundstram is really coming on to a game but for the money we are paying him I'd expect him to be the best player on the pitch every game. I'm not sure we will get that out of him and I can see him being here for the length of his contract and leave on a free.

Wright is poor. No sale value.

Bacuna was a poor signing but we got him for nothing and shifted him out the door quickly. Hopefully we aren't paying a contribution to his wage.

Sakala I can't see him ever being more than a bit part player and he'll end up back at the level of club he was playing at before us.

Who knows with Ofoborh. Looks a horrific waste of wages.

If Ramsey scores the winner in the Europa League final then the signing will be a success and we will be an instant hero. If we end up winning nothing this year it's an expensive shambles of a signing.

Sands looks ok. We still have another year to evaluate.

Zukowski is apparently terrible and not even good enough for the B team. 

First ive seen or heard that. 

[BlueKnight87 17,832]

McLaughlin, Bassey, Hagi, Balogun Roofe Lundstram.

[WWTC 2,450]

How the fuck are you suppose to make a call on Weston? 

[Valance1690 4,090]

Need to look at it based on how much we spent, it's the reason why Kent is criticised so much

From that list, Hagi & Roofe stand out, best part of 10 million there, we need players like that to step up & dominate up here & they simply don't do it anywhere near enough.

Hagi especially, for how much he seems to be a fan favourite, his numbers are horrific.

[BlueSuedeSambas 56,312]

1 hour ago, DiamondDan said:

Someone voted Diallo 😂

Bet it was @falkirkNS. He’s a big Diallo fan

 

[Bigdave30 9,099]

That list, for the most part, makes me want to burst into fucking tears, what a shambles.

[McEwan's Lager 31,970]

41 minutes ago, WWTC said:

First ive seen or heard that. 

Heard he's been really poor in his appearances for them in the Glasgow Cup. 

[TamCoopz 19,877]

2 hours ago, HG5 said:

Given it’s success (1 trophy out of 16 competed for, and I know that could possibly rise by one or two) maybe it’s time to look at our system?

As half the team will be gone over the summer, no time like the present!

How fucking grim is that 

[EMRFC 4,913]

3 of these players have been here for 2 months… bit unfair to judge them. People writing off Sands is annoying as fuck.

[HG5 12,175]

41 minutes ago, TamCoopz said:

How fucking grim is that 

It is when you look at it like that.

Again, it may change, but St Johnstone have won more in this period…